Sauce Gardner to the Colts for 2 1st round picks (and AD Mitchell)

[st pete gogolak]

This back and forth reminds me of the discussion (such as it was) regarding who won the Ryan O’Reilly trade.  Doesn’t matter how many 40 goal seasons Tage Thompson has. Blues won a Cup and O’Reilly was playoff MVP. Blues won the trade. Similar to the Stanford trade. If Colts somehow manage to win a Super Bowl with Gardner, they win the trade.

[Krakensabres]

32 minutes ago, st pete gogolak said:

This back and forth reminds me of the discussion (such as it was) regarding who won the Ryan O’Reilly trade.  Doesn’t matter how many 40 goal seasons Tage Thompson has. Blues won a Cup and O’Reilly was playoff MVP. Blues won the trade. Similar to the Stanford trade. If Colts somehow manage to win a Super Bowl with Gardner, they win the trade.

Gardner doesn’t make the colts a SB contender - they have a fake good Qb who will become a pumpkin come playoff time 

[Jrb1979]

4 minutes ago, Krakensabres said:

Gardner doesn’t make the colts a SB contender - they have a fake good Qb who will become a pumpkin come playoff time 

They could catch lightning on a bottle like the Bengals did a few years ago and win a Super Bowl. 

 

This mindset of not willing to sacrifice the future to win now. This whole thought of "if everything goes our way and we are lucky and win a Super Bowl great". I don't want to go back to the drought years so make sure you don't trade that 3rd or 4th round pick to help this team now. 

[Mr. WEO]

Wow, Woody Johnson actually made another owner look like a sucker!

[ChronicAndKnuckles]

10 hours ago, IYKYK said:

The colts remind me of the Vikings a couple of years ago. They got off to a great start and fell apart in the end of the season. 

Yes. That’s a solid comparison. I feel like the wheels are gonna fall off with Daniel Jones. 

[Captain Hindsight]

1 hour ago, st pete gogolak said:

This back and forth reminds me of the discussion (such as it was) regarding who won the Ryan O’Reilly trade.  Doesn’t matter how many 40 goal seasons Tage Thompson has. Blues won a Cup and O’Reilly was playoff MVP. Blues won the trade. Similar to the Stanford trade. If Colts somehow manage to win a Super Bowl with Gardner, they win the trade.

Yup. You think the Lions or Rams won the Goff/Stafford? 
 

Lions made some great moves with it, Rams won a title

 

Unless the lions win one too, the winner will always be the Rams

[Buffalo716]

37 minutes ago, Captain Hindsight said:

Yup. You think the Lions or Rams won the Goff/Stafford? 
 

Lions made some great moves with it, Rams won a title

 

Unless the lions win one too, the winner will always be the Rams

If anybody thinks this trade makes the colts Super bowl favorites I got a bridge to sell you in Brooklyn 

 

Really good price 

 

Indy certainly did not win this trade.. nothing like the Stafford trade

Edited 1 hour ago by Buffalo716