At what point do you cut your losses with Maybin?

[WordByrd]

Yesterday

[Heels20X6]

I love when people bring up his salary as a reason to cut him...like we pay him directly out of our pockets. Also, if we cut him, what makes you think Ralph would spend the money strengthening the position?

 

The kid works hard and is still developing, if he's showing nothing after next year, then cut him.

[DIE HARD 1967]

I love when people bring up his salary as a reason to cut him...like we pay him directly out of our pockets. Also, if we cut him, what makes you think Ralph would spend the money strengthening the position?

 

The kid works hard and is still developing, if he's showing nothing after next year, then cut him.

 

I love it when people believe money means nothing and overpaid players should just clean locker rooms after the game!

 

I am giving him 2 full seasons and 3 training camps. I didn't even say he needed to be great!

 

But, he needs to play at a much higher level OR he is a rip off and I will spend the money elsewhere.

Edited August 22, 2010 by DIE HARD 1967

[Kelso_Helmet]

Young...hard worker...speed...

 

Sounds like he'd make a solid special teams player. Even with a fair degree of latitude given for his age, not an impressive showing as a pass rusher or run stopper when he's been on the field, even in preseason against other teams' marginal talent. Personally, I don't see the exponential improvement happening that he'd need to be worth a #1 pick, or necessarily even a starter on a good defense.

 

Hope I'm wrong.

[C.Biscuit97]

I think fans have been way too patient with Maybin. They probably should have cut him after the 4th preseason game his rookie year.

[DIE HARD 1967]

Young...hard worker...speed...

 

Sounds like he'd make a solid special teams player. Even with a fair degree of latitude given for his age, not an impressive showing as a pass rusher or run stopper when he's been on the field, even in preseason against other teams' marginal talent. Personally, I don't see the exponential improvement happening that he'd need to be worth a #1 pick, or necessarily even a starter on a good defense.

 

Hope I'm wrong.

 

He clearly need to make an impact THIS SEASON. Something, anything......block a punt,sack a 2nd string QB.....something!

[MyHorseAteTheKid]

I'm remaining hopeful Maybin can be a big time pro!!!

[Pirate Angel]

He was drafted as a project and was only 21 years old...It is said that it takes 3 years to judge a draft...so you have

1) a young very raw talent coming out of college

2) is now learning a new position in his second year

3) is now under his second coaching staff in his second year

I have never agreed with the pick of Maybin but hes here for a while so we may as well support him.. there are other players on the roster that we could be complaining about... McCargo, Kirk Chambers, Fitzpatrick, etc..

[DIE HARD 1967]

I'm remaining hopeful Maybin can be a big time pro!!!

 

I believe his chances are about 50/50.

 

Wait and see, if he plays well some fan will say "I" wanted to waive him.

 

Nooooo, I said he gets one more full year and a 2011 training camp ( if there is one). If he looks no better, then SEE YA

Edited August 22, 2010 by DIE HARD 1967

[stony]

I love it when people believe money means nothing and overpaid players should just clean locker rooms after the game!

 

I am giving him 2 full seasons and 3 training camps. I didn't even say he needed to be great!

 

But, he needs to play at a much higher level OR he is a rip off and I will spend the money elsewhere.

 

Ahhh, but you're assuming we would actually spend the money elsewhere.

[DIE HARD 1967]

Ahhh, but you're assuming we would actually spend the money elsewhere.

 

So you are saying we should keep him BECAUSE we won't spend the money elsewhere, either way YOU lose!

Edited August 22, 2010 by DIE HARD 1967

[The Dean]

I love it when people believe money means nothing and overpaid players should just clean locker rooms after the game!

 

I am giving him 2 full seasons and 3 training camps. I didn't even say he needed to be great!

 

But, he needs to play at a much higher level OR he is a rip off and I will spend the money elsewhere.

 

 

I agree with much of what you say in this thread. But I have to say, I don't really care about what a player gets paid, unless he is under-performing his contract and that is preventing this team from picking up someone else. As the team has operated under the cap, for the most part, for a few years, I don't think that is an issue at the moment

 

I believe his chances are about 50/50.

 

Wait and see, if he plays well some fan will say "I" wanted to waive him.

 

Nooooo, I said he gets one more full year and a 2011 training camp ( if there is one). If he looks no better, then SEE YA

 

 

50-50? You have a bit more confidence than I, but I think we both agree it's OK at this point it time, to give the guy a shot.

[stony]

So you are saying we should keep him BECAUSE we won't spend the money elsewhere, either way YOU lose!

 

Not at all. Contracts are in a sense, an investment on the future potential of a player. Especially rookie contracts. There is no fiscal reason to cut him so early especially after a protracted holdout last year that one can assume is beneficial in part to both sides. His contract is already in the future plans of the team, so its not like the FO is saying each offseason, "damn it, I wish we could make a move but Maybin's contract is screwing us." Comparing the returns of a rookie's deal (or second year player) to that of a free agent is wrong and misleading, something a think a lot of people do when looking at Maybin compared to other player's deals. For better or worse, its apples and oranges.

[nick in* england]

Maybin is a major disappointment. He was projected as a 3-4 OLB and has failed to grasp that role in the first year he has been given the chance to play that position.

 

Apart from flashes of speed, i've seen nothing to impress me on a pass rush front, really not great use of his hands, and he has no bull rush to speak of.

 

He needs to show something now that Torbor is out for a while, or else he is going to be riding the pine and looking for a new job in January.

[eball]

If you are the coach or GM you have to ask "Do I see the light at the end of the tunnel? Is there an upside here that is realistic?"

 

I assume Buddy and Chan ask these things of all under-performing players on a regular basis.

 

The guy has big speed, seemingly a great work ethic and he's VERY young (the 2nd youngest player on the team, I think).

 

While he didn't light it up in the first game, he showed plenty of speed and stick-to-itiveness. On Thursday he didn't show much at all in his limited time with the scrubs.

 

Maybe they have already made their decision and he isn't in their plans. Or maybe they have decided he is going to be a situational player this year.

 

Calling him names, questioning his character, etc are simply stupid reactions from fans who didn't like him as the draft pick, it seems.

I pretty much agree with these comments, Dean. I'm not impressed with Maybin so far, but you have to believe Nix/Gailey are asking these questions.

[BillsMan75]

I have my own time frame with Maybin but yours may be different.

 

At some point YOU have to cut your losses and move on...........

 

Personally, I give him this season and perhaps one more preseason to drastically improve, after that, SEE YA!

 

I am all for patience, but we need more from a #1 draft pick. It's money vs production

 

There is no right or wrong answer with a time frame to cut ties, it depends on your patience level.

 

Your opinion is important to me and I respect your thoughts on the matter.

 

GO BILLS!

 

-DIEHARD 1967

 

Maybin has no ties to this Administration. I say if he can't cut it and get into the starting rotation, you gotta cut him. He's a first rounder costing us a-lot of money. I can't see paying the guy what he's getting paid to be a backup for the back ups. Right now he's part of the third string defense.

[RyanC883]

I just hope we've cut our ties to the morons who drafted him with the 11th OP. This team's dismal decade past is only mirrored by it's legacy of horrendous drafting in the early rounds.

 

 

Exactly. The blame here is not with Maybin, but with those who drafted him at #11 and passed up Oher and Okrakpo, etc.

[Chandler#81]

I think we've got something in this kid. Freak speed and -contrary to other's opinions- loves to play. I believe he'll be a starter this year.

[first_and_ten]

He came out too early, he is younger than half the rookies and given time I think he'll grow into his job. He'll probably backup this year and get enough experience to start next year.

 

You make a good point.He came out early so that fact probably buys him a little bit more time. I'm hoping you're right about next year. It did concern me to see him playing deep into the fourth quarter when all the "scrubs" are in the game. Maybe Gailey thinks he needs the reps.

[billsfreak]

I have my own time frame with Maybin but yours may be different.

 

At some point YOU have to cut your losses and move on...........

 

Personally, I give him this season and perhaps one more preseason to drastically improve, after that, SEE YA!

 

I am all for patience, but we need more from a #1 draft pick. It's money vs production

 

There is no right or wrong answer with a time frame to cut ties, it depends on your patience level.

 

Your opinion is important to me and I respect your thoughts on the matter.

 

GO BILLS!

 

-DIEHARD 1967

It is far too early now to give up on a first round pick, especially switching to a defense that supposedly will fit him better. I say, like you, give him until about this time next season to improve, if not dump him in the final cuts before the season starts in 2011 (if there is a season, that is).