Cutler made it to the pro bowl because of his raw numbers, not because he was especially good. He may have thrown for 4500 yards but he needed the 9th most pass attempts of all time to do it. He also had 20 turnovers, even though he had a top 5 receiving corps, offensive line, and running game. He also consistently ranks #1 in bad decision % among starting QBs. I would say Jeff George is a very apt comparison, and one that quite a few people are starting to make.