What magazines? Bryan Scott is a former CB who runs a 4.8-4.9 40. That's LB speed on a safety... which is NOT good enough to cover a WR. They started Scott because Whitner was the only one on the team that could play FS, and Scott is way, way, way too slow to play it. Whitner is by far the superior overall player, and would be starting no question if he wasn't injured. George Wilson is clearly inferior to Donte Whitner, or have you forgotten all those plays where Wilson was 10 yards away from a receiver as he walks into the end zone?
Do you really want to get into this argument PushThePile? You argued all summer that Jay Cutler was a very good QB, and look how that turned out.