ChicagoRic

He's a serviceable starter for now. It's always interesting to see if a young player can stay productive as the game tape starts to accrue. He does look a bit better than Mac Jones, but can he maintain it. See: Gardner Minshew

I just want to see some ENERGY outta the guy. He reminds me of my orange cat, Cooper, who expends no more energy than is absolutely needed. Slow to the huddle. Slow to the sidelines. His longer stride looks.....slow. Maybe it's deceptive. My orange cat can really motor......when it wants to. But it really really has to want to. If riding the pine does not light a fire under this guy, maybe a ton of reps will? What will motivate this guy to start playing like he did in college?

Needs more carries and they should be at expense of Zach Moss, but yeah, I am worries. Unscientifically, his body language is all off. Looks uncertain out there, and defenses feed of that. He is not his brother, that is clear. Who are what he is remains in question, and we won't know if he only gets the call a few times a game.

Long term health comes first. Person before player. Next up.

Jaquan Johnson looked last year in spot duty and again in preseason. Taron Johnson, Siran Neal, and Cam Lewis know the system and the rookies have held up so far. Poyer is off to a great start this season. More importantly, our base deep shell pass defense is designed to take the top off of a passing game. Tua looked good last week, but I don't expect a repeat performance.

Good for him. I wish him luck. Now please please please put Moss on the bench forever. Singletary can do everything better and maybe just maybe Cook can live up to his hype.

There ya go, James Cook. Show me more of that!

Defense has got to tighten up and Zach Moss needs to sit on offense.

No reason not to kick the FG

What I'd love to see is Cook juke some guy out of his shorts and get out into the open field.

Maybe it's the running style that throws me off. Not really seeing the speed, but "glide" runners in the mold of Chris Warren from back in the day don't really show it.

Hoping to see more from him. Wondering if he's the kind of guy who needs touches to get into a rhythm.

Calling it now. Blackshear is gonna "feature back" it tonight while also returning kicks and playing gunner. He may get cut, but he'll go out in style.

I actually took the time to watch Blackshear's college highlights and came away with a few things. 1) Runs well between the tackles. Follows his block, makes the cut and gets upfield quick. 2) Does not give up on plays. Saw quite a few examples where he was able to bounce out and finish a play when the initial hole was plugged. 3) Very natural catching the ball. Soft hands and catches in stride. Saw a few where he plucked low throws from inches off the turf transitoned smoothly North-South again. 4) Made lots of chunk plays. Plenty of 10-15 yarders... but is not a home run threat as he does not have the hyperdrive gear when he gets loose. Also noticed in the preseason games that he is actually pretty active on special teams. Very much doubt he makes the cut, but it would be nice to see him on the practice squad as a sorta of poor man's James Cook. If Cook were injured he could fill the role.

Agreed. He can hit the hole and make the cut. Required in the NFL. I'm still waiting for that WOW play. Looking for something on the level of the the precision and polish that Shakir has shown at WR against starting DBs..

Gonna be the voice of dissent. In the preseason, it's been 7 runs and 2 catches and they have all looked.......fine......but not special. Even in the video above, he simply followed his blocks and broke one crappy arm tackle. Not exactly a special play. Holding off on the accolades until he shows me more.

Blackshear for PS for sure. Made some nice runs and pass receptions and looked smooth doing it. Not a jitterbug by any means, but he seems to know when to time his cuts. I thought he was done for the game after the injury but when the camera caught him on the sidelines you could just see how badly he wanted to be out there, ankle or not. Although he did not touch the ball once he came back in, he willed himself to there and the coaching staff rewarded that force of will. That's the kind of attitude and player I want to see on the PS. He's not Singletary or Moss or Cook. He's not this years Duke Williams. He may never see a snap in a regular season NFL game for the Bills or any other team, but it sure as ***** won't be because he quit on himself. Dude wants it, and that kind of attitude is great for team culture.

Don't be fooled by "Preseason Rudolph". Rudolph always looks good in camp/practice/preseason but falls apart when the bullets start flying.

Because it's a discussion forum, perhaps?

Positionally. McKenzie will take that slot. Sanders and Kumerow would both line up wide opposite Diggs. Although Sanders can just as easily play slot too.

It's next man up time. My vote goes to McKenzie as he steps out of the doghouse into the Beasley role while Kumerow competes with Sanders for snaps.

I guess I am a yay-sayer. After such a long drought, I am sincerely happy that we are now consistently fielding a legit playoff caliber team. That being said, I expect the Bills to win this one handily. The Bills have demonstrated again and again they can rattle rookie QBs. Mac Jones is.......a nice story, but he's not the second coming of Brady. We got this.

Yes, same for me. Numbers aside, it just seems like Singletary does not have the "it factor". It's hard to explain, but in crucial moments he can't be counted on to make a spark or a statement play. The 2nd effort. The "angry run". All too often it's "Singletary, open in the flat.....and he drops the ball" or "It's 3rd and 2, here's Singletary off the left side......and it looks like he's a foot short". Hard to quantify.

3 years in, and I still don't have this guy figured out. On one hand, his yards per carry has been consistently good. 5.0 yards per carry this season. He's our leading rusher. He's a willing an able blocker. On the other hand, when the time comes for him to make a crucial first down (12 this year, on 80 carries, and just 3 broken tackles) or punch it in the end zone (6 career TDs over 3 years), he always seems to come up short. He coughs up the ball at crucial moments (5 fumbles this year). When he has an open field ahead of him, he drops the easy pass (10.7% drop percentage). I like the way he runs..until the Bills really NEED a play to happen. Then, he's the last offensive player I want to touch the ball. So, what is he? Good player? Bad player? Just a guy?

Gotta ask.... does the ref understand that this is football...these roughness penalties are.......weak