Lost

I know he's a 3rd down back but this almost feels like an underpay. Ty has been clutch for us

I think Keon comes across as almost over confident. As though he thinks he can dominate out there without much extra work or effort. Hopefully the back half of last season has taught him that there is indeed a learning curve for the NFL, no matter how good you think you are.

These free agent signings have been pretty uninspiring for the Bills so far. We have cap money now and all the elite names are spoken for and yet we have the league leader in TDs and second best player on our offense from last year sitting here waiting for a new contract. 15 million/year seems like a bargain for the contracts that have been flying around out there this weekend. There, I said it. Flame away.

Bills had the #1 ranked defense in the NFL in 2021 but still let the 13 seconds debacle happen and did absolutely nothing in OT to stop them from marching right down the field and winning.

I would talk him into retiring and offer him a coaching role of some kind.

Interesting point that I haven't considered. Leonard Floyd might have been the best free agent signing Brandon Beane has made with Buffalo. I would happily take his production again for $9 million a year.

In light of the ongoing debate over which big name player we might trade for(Myles Garrett or DK Metcalf) perhaps a more objective way of looking at it might be to evaluate which overall stat lines would equate to more wins so I present this poll with players names removed.

Trent Edwards JP Losman Kyle Orton Todd Collins ... ... ... ... Josh Allen Jim Kelly

Was it clean? I thought it was helmet to helmet.

Still can't believe Brian Thomas Jr was sitting there at 24 and coulda been had with a modest trade up. I'll take his immediate production over whatever hodge podge of mid talent we got for trading down to take Coleman. I swear Beane must do all of his shopping on Temu.

Actually I had previously laughed at the possibility of the Bills considering bringing in someone like Dionte Johnson to complete the WR room but looking at this chart below has me reconsidering.

We need a separator and IMO any receiver approaching or past the age of 30 cannot be that. Lets just trade for Garret Wilson and call it a day.

Would you consider that an overpay if Beane gives him that much?

Not if they're keeping the same run first offensive philosophy next season. Both those backs are great pass catchers. Ray Davis still spends a little too much time dancing in the backfield for my liking though.

Do newsgroups still exist?

That list is lacking a Tremaine Edmunds thread... Color me disappointed 🤨

I haven't heard Booth's named mentioned since the draft til just now. Has that guy even played?

Not sure how to feel about this. Love Cook but that feels like a lot. On the other hand Beane has a history of overpaying for mid or washed talent so if he's going to overpay I'd rather it be someone who actually produces. Cook has been excellent the last two seasons.

Todd Collins? 😂

Love this guy

Eagles are just good at team building and talent evaluation. Credit to Howie Roseman.

Drafting culture and one's ability to play special teams seems to take priority over actual physical talent under McBeane.

I'm still recovering from left shark