Virgil

I should have know this would have gone into who's overall better. It's not what I'm asking. I'm talking about just based off this game and if Peterman won the game in a fraction of the time. Ignore concussion protocol, remove your opinion of who is better. Just based off that scenario.

Wasn't attacking you boss, just calling out the info that I'm sure many are waiting for. I just made an overly long post about it.

With everyone talking about what it would take to trade up, I figured I would put this out there so people can do their own math and decide what's worth it. This is based off a 2017 article stating the draft chart was updated by teams last year. The one floating around on NBCSports is rumored to be out of date. The Bills own picks: 21 - 260 points 22 - 252 points 53 - 106 points 56 - 98 points 85 (roughly) - 50 points 117 (roughly) - 24 points 149 (roughly) - 12 points 2019 1st (guess) - 160 points *It also says that draft picks in the following years draft are worth one round's lower points. So our 1st pick next year is worth 2nd round points this year. With that being said, to trade up would theoretically cost... 1st pick - Our entire first 4 rounds of picks and the 1st and 2nd in next years (Cleveland probably isn't trading out of this anyways) 2nd pick - All 4 picks from the first and second round (A lot better than getting 1st overall and Giants would listen) 3rd pick - Both 1st round picks (Colts would listen. I doubt this would actually get it done) 4th pick - One of our 1st round picks, both of our 2nds, and our 3rd (Cleveland should be open for business) Keeping a 1st would be huge 5th pick - One of 1st, 2nd's, and 3rd pick (Denver will probably be looking QB unless they get Cousins. If they don't get him, I see them staying or trading up) 6th pick - Both 1st's (According to NBC sports and some other journalist opinions. Higher than this chart) 7th pick - Same as for a 5th, just the lower of each rounds picks 8th pick - Our second 1st round pick and our 1st round pick next year (If this landed us Mayfield, I'm all over it) 9th pick - Our 1st, 2nd, and 4th 10th pick - Our 1st and 2nd To me, outside getting the number one overall pick, there's nothing here I can't live with. I don't know that I would make a trade before the draft as much as I would see how things pan out. I have no idea which quarterback they deem worthy of a pick. I think Mayfield goes between 5-10 in the draft. If that happens, and the brass likes him, our team gets him, keeps a 1st and 2nd, plus we have free agency. I'd be very excited going into next season. Thanks for staying with me.

This needs it’s own thread as it will probably be the most talked about ideas for the next four months

If Peterman won the game after entering late, would you start him against the Pats next week? I know some of you hate these, so feel free to ignore and move on. For me, if he orchestrated the game tying TD and later game winning score, I give him the keys in the final week. However, I don’t think McDermott makes that decision again. Thoughts? Changing starting QB mid post season?

If you are making me choose, I'm keeping TT. TT was part of the offense with Roman and Lynn which scored a lot of points because the offense was tailored to his strengths. However, his deep ball has regressed. Both need to go though. TT is a strong back-up or bridge qb

That's like being proud of banging the school slut. Slowing down our offense is something most teams have done this year

My first playoff game review and the last one of the season. Today felt like a different game from the time I woke up and had a much different feeling when it was over. I don't have the same defeated attitude nor am I terribly upset. A part of me would rather lose a close game this week than a probable blow-out next week. Maybe that's a defeatist attitude, but today was a bonus and the ultimate goal of ending the drought in a rebuilding year was accomplished. 1 - Tyrod - I'm just going to this out of the way now because I don't want to focus on the negatives too much. Tyrod most likely played his last game for the Bills unless he's used as our bridge quarterback. However, after this game, I don't even know if I'd bring him back for that. I also don't know that he's going to have much trade value either. Never mind the 3 total points he scored, but his inability to hit a pass more than 10 yards downfield has regressed the most of all his skills. He missed a clear TD on the FG drive and Thompson deep on the final drive. Both guys had a clear few steps and those throws need to be made. He also threw two out routes short of the posts. Overall, his entire game was a series of 5 yard passes and was never a thread to the Jags defense. Thank you for getting us to the playoffs Tyrod, but if they can find a better bridge quarterback or their guy in the draft, then it's time we part ways. But first and foremost, thank you. 2 - Dennison - While TT can be blamed for a lot of missed throws, Dennison needs to take his share of the blame for calling plays that TT clearly can't make. Has TT hit a single fade route all year? Where's the WR screens? TT may be limited, and I'm sure McDermott will watch all the game field to see if the plays were there and TT couldn't execute, but I think it's a combination of both. Dennison should be on the way out as he wasn't the first choice and a truly uninspiring hire. If we go QB in the draft, then we really need to get our guy to make sure our new QB can stay comfortable in a stable system. 3 - Refs - The Refs were not the reason we lost this game. However, I'm just tired of seeing reviews go against the Bills. The INT should have been overturned as the ball hit the ground twice as he rolled over it. That's the kind of call that seems to keep going against the Bills, no matter what the play is on the field. Also, maybe I need to read the rules again, but I'm surprised the tackle that knocked TT out of the game wasn't a penalty. That was a full-on head lock and forced TT from the game. If that's Brady, it's definitely a penalty. Again, today was just for of the same with 5-/50 calls going against the Bills 4 - Thanks, that was fun Don't forget, no regrets Except maybe one Made a deal not to feel 5 - Lorax - I haven't called Lorax out in my reviews at all this year, but he was the defensive MVP today. Lorax was all over the field and blew up some plays in the backfield. He shot the gap on a few plays and really did a fantastic job. I would have liked to see more from him this season, but he showed up when he had to. 6 - Schmidt - Both punters did an amazing job switching fields today. Schmidt only had one questionable punt where he seemed to be out on the field more than any other player. I'd be curious to know if a record was broken for most punts downed inside the 20 in a playoff game. 7 - Defensive Pressure - I finally got what I asked for going into a game. We stacked 8 in the box, kept one safety deep, and really shut down the run and deep pass. While against an inept offense, this was the defensive effort we needed today. The stand after the tipped Int was HUGE as it kept a field goal off the board. It's frustrating that the effort was wasted, but it created some optimism for me going forward. If we can get a DT who can push the middle of the pocket, I think this goes back to being a top 5 defense. 8 - Last two minutes of first half - Anyone else just know we were going to give up points? The stupid penalty, the 3 and out, allowing Bortles to scramble....That was our most Billsy moment and to me killed our momentum the most. 9 - Secondary - In a game where Bortles had more rushing yards than passing, a big shout out goes to the secondary. Almost every defensive back had a big play. White better when DROY and I'm excited to have Poyer and Hyde together for the next few years. Gaines will be the biggest defensive offseason question for the team, but I like what we've put together so far. 10 - McDermott - The Bills were ready for today, but the lack of talent on offense lost to a more talented defense. Our defense was fantastic all game. We shut down the run and pass while only giving up 10 points on the road in the playoffs. You can complain about the Bortles scrambles, but to have everything else shut down, have multiple opportunities to win, is all you can ask for. Any team would take 10 opposing points. Overall, I feel better about our Head Coach than I have any during the 17 year drought. I have faith in what him and Beane will get done this offseason and expect to see evolution next season. Thank you as well McDermott as you gave all of us one of our best weeks as a Bills fan. Until next year guys, Go Bills!!!

Now that Sammy’s season is over and Free Agency awaits him, I’m curious as to what his value will be. As a Bills fan, we saw glimpses of brilliance. Many of us argued that his lack of production was because he was a decoy, we didn’t have a QB that could get him the ball, or he had nagging injuries. This seaon, all of those excuses were gone and he still disappears from games. I can’t understand how his obvious potential doesn’t sustain in games, but the result is what it is. To me, the 2nd round pick and Gaines was a robbery by us. With all of that, what kind of deal do you think he pulls in and where does he go? I think he either settles for a 1 year deal or gets 3 years at 8-10 mil from someone like the Bears. Thoughts?

Considering their normal attendance, I suspect that a lot of those early sales were to re-sellers. I think we will have a strong showing

The only thing I agree with about this article is that it felt like they were gearing up for a final run this offseason. They made trades and signed guys in ways they normally don’t. The Jimmy G thing is interesting if true, but the rest doesn’t seem like anything of substance that would cause the team to disband like it suggests.

Stack 8 in the box, Poyer deep. Let White and Gaines play man and dare Bortles to beat us. I trust our secondary to allow us to stack the box, shut down Fournette and chase Bortles into bad throws.

Jury is still out on those guys. I’m not sold on Mahomes or Watson yet. We won’t know for a few years. I was glad we passed on them, made the playoffs, and have the ammo we do now in this draft.

The more I think about it, I think I’m staying put unless it’s a minor trade up into the Teens for Rudolph or Mayfield. I think Rudolph is the only one having a shot of still being there. If it doesn’t happen and we roll with Tyrod and get quality around him, I think we can sell the farm next year for a QB. Most teams will have gotten them this year, so there’s less competition. And we need to solidify a lot of holes. I think that adding the depth changes a few of those blowout losses this year and we are a better team. This isn’t a positive vote for TT, but I just can’t justify losing so much potential talent for a “Maybe” QB. Ideally, I would want Cousins and use our picks like normal. I think we are a 10-6/11-5 team in that scenario and we have the cap room.

I’ve seen mocks with him going in the top 15. Don’t underestimate the panic that kicks in when the 3 of the top 5 are drafted. This is why I think Mayfield is the guy. Wasn’t there a report about us heavily scouting him? And we definitely need to trade up to get him

Let this be a lesson to all of you about posting when you are tired

Don’t underestimate teams trading up. In your top 10 right now you have the Browns, Giants, and Jets. They could and should all go QB. Thankfully the 49ers are set now. But don’t discount the Redskins, Cardinals, or Cardinals trading up. Everyone is going to want their guy and at least 4 of them could the top ranked player on a teams board. I think it’s going to be a frenzy with the most trades we’ve seen so far. The Colts, Browns, and 49ers could all be looking to trade back and get picks.

It’s just never going to get old

With the announcements of Darnold and Rosen entering the draft, we now have at least 5 QB’s that will most likely go in the first round, maybe all in the top 10. Unfortunately, there’s a lot of quarterback hungry teams out there. If you aren’t in the top 5 and want one, I think the Colts are your chance to trade up, but that’s going to cost us a lot of our picks, if not all of them. So, for those who want one of those QBs, would you sacrifice all those other main picks for him or do you keep the picks, build a solid overall team, and hope for a QB that falls, FA, or next year? Personally, I’m torn because I would love to see a Mayfield here. But I think we could shore up almost every other position with all of our picks and get a lot better still. Then either enter the Cousins sweepstakes or draft one next year when all these teams have their QBs. *I’m assuming most of our picks would be needed to trade from the 20’s to 3. I’d guess both 1sts this year and next, our 2nd and 3rd this year as well. So we’d get Mayfield, a 2nd, 5th major pick this year. Worth it?

Nope. I also prefer Pepsi to coke

Oh no, that’s horrible and stuff..... !@#$ him. He’s 2nd on my hate list now. He bumped the hoodie

Exactly She has a face? also, is there a name? For research purposes....

If it was so easy, why didn’t it happen in the past 17 years? If it’s luck this year that 9-7 made it, were we always just really that unlucky? Is luck the deciding factor? Yes, we were 9-7, but we were a better 9-7 than two other teams. We won games we normally lost. I’m sorry, but I’m not buying what you’re selling. This was a special season and we saw glimpses of it at times. We aren’t great...yet.

I wish I could say I was looking forward to that matchup. But it there’s something to be said for meeting the same team 3 times in 5 weeks.

McSavior?