FireChans

My post was about if the WR's are "good." The folks who think that the WR's aren't "good" is comparing them to the rest of the NFL. If you have no interest in that, there's no reason to dispute it either.

See above. I just want to know, who on that list is below Shakir or Coleman or MVS or Mack right now? For example, If your opinion is that Shakir and Coleman are both top 15 guys on this list, then its totally fair to think this group is good.

No, that's not what I'm saying. See I'm very comfortable saying that Josh is much better than his numbers. I think he's the best QB in the NFL this season thus far despite his passing numbers. I think he's better right now than Mahomes/Burrow/LJ etc. What I'm doing is trying to provide context of the WR's on this team. If you are confident that Shakir is the fifth best WR on that list and MVS and Coleman and Hollins are in the top 15 on that list, that's certainly your opinion. I just don't share that opinion. But I would like to hear the opinion of you guys who think this WR group is very good. Because "good" is relative.

This is fair, but the Dolphins WRs are objectively great and the Chiefs/Pats WR's were objectively not great. There's really two sides to this equation. 1. Can the Bills run an enough good enough to win a Superbowl with this WR crew? - Early returns say yes. The offense has been humming thus far, and Brady is in his bag and Josh is playing really excellent. Long season, but plenty to be optimistic about. 2. Is this WR crew considered "good" by NFL standards - This is still very debateable. Illustrated below. Here are the top 30ish WR's on the list this season by yardage. Nabers Collins Lamb Rice Jennings JJ Metcalf Godwin Smith Pierce Chase Adams Jamo St Brown MHJ Reed Hill Robinson BTJ Olave Waddle JSN Reynolds Pickens Mooney Shaheed (Shakir) Moore Diggs Tolbert Odunze Meyers Wilson Flowers That list is in receiving yards. A very imperfect stat. But how many players on that list do you think Shakir and co. are better than?

I don't know about you, but I can't even imagine a great QB missing an open receiver in the endzone at the end of the game vs the Chiefs.

Every year, everyone goes "multiple of these rookie QB's can be at least good to great QB's" and then fastforward 3 years and like one of them at most is even okay. The Trevor Lawrence/Mac Jones/Justin Fields class didn't seem so bad after their first or second years. Fastforward to today, everyone from that class has been cut or traded except Trevor, and Trevor has 1 playoff berth in his career.

There is nothing to debate and I’m not trying to silence anyone. The OP did not respond to support his claim that Lamar is a “below average” QB. He threw a grenade and ran. It’s a total joke.

@Coach Tuesday this is what a bat signal for prejudice looks like, fyi.

Rank your top 32 QB’s and I will explain to you in excruciating and painful detail why Lamar is nowhere close to number 17 on that list.

Losing to the defending champs on the last play in a one score game after putting up 300 yards of offense makes you a BUM.

He’s a two time MVP. Of course they are. are there any two time MVPs not in the Hall?

That Lamar is a “million times better” than Josh? I don’t think so haha.

Does anyone believe this?

That’s life fellas. Ravens +3 folks were that close. They don’t cash. That’s how it goes.

KC -3 and the over, never a doubt.

Shades of KD

I didn’t say press. I said line up outside. Read the posts my guy.

Facts lol. You are seeing a maximum of 30% of the game. Maybe wait til you can actually see the whole game before calling the 30% of what you can see a “fact.”

Bro you can’t even see the whole field on broadcast, miss me with this fake analysis.

That kinda lends credence to the idea that teams aren’t just gonna erase him if he lines up outside, yeah?

If Coleman has 68 yards and 2 TD’s on Sunday, I will be ecstatic. I don’t care if the entire defense falls down.

Why did they trade up if they were confident they would get him at 32? They just wanted to give the Bills some picks to help them out?

He has 2 TD’s and 68 yards.

Lmao

I can’t believe he got off the line. I was told if he lined up outside, he would be pile driven into the Gatorade jugs.