CincyBillsFan

"But at the end of the day, given these statistics and this analysis, it’s hard to look at the Bills and think they can “get over the hump” in the playoffs if only Allen would play better."

This is the money quote form the analysis: "But at the end of the day, given these statistics and this analysis, it’s hard to look at the Bills and think they can “get over the hump” in the playoffs if only Allen would play better."

I agree with your first sentence then you have to go and ruin it with your last paragraph. Sure, Allen had the ball in his hands those last two games but in the NFL you shouldn't miss 44 yard FG's and drop passes that hit your hands. Sorry, but poor defense has been the key reason the Bills have lost each of their last 5 playoff games. Not the only reason but the main reason. So while I believe like you that Allen has no intention of forcing his way out anytime soon and that he wants to deliver a SB to Buffalo more then anything else, let's see how things look in three years if the Bills continue to exit the playoffs playing bad defense and no one else making a play at a critical time in the game.

This thought exercise goes a long way towards showing that Allen has not enjoyed the kind of superior trifecta that other elite QB's have enjoyed at different points in their careers. As an aside you could argue that for the Chiefs the trifecta of Mahomes, Kelsy & Hill or going back further Dawson, Garret & Taylor were better then Montana, Allen & Davis

Given what we've seen from Allen on the availability front through his first 7 years I suspect that he is looking more like a unicorn then a dog from a longevity standpoint. IMO 5 years would be the absolute minimum that he's at his best physically, 7 - 8 years seems more likley with a gradual fall off after that.

The point here is sound though - this is, on paper, a very favorable schedule with respect to where the Bills are playing their hardest games. In addition having 9 home games is no small thing.

Interesting that only Bishop & Davis got a couple of positive comments from the rankings. I didn't know Bishop had 10 tackles in the Championship game.

I agree. He has every right and in fact an obligation to try to get as much money as he can get. The RB position has been underpaid the last few years and 15 million per year is not crazy given his production. Now if the Bills think they can get similar production from someone else then play hardball with Cook and get someone to replace him.

I am confident Bishop will turn heads next season after a full preseason/training camp. He actually flashed against the run and unless we sign someone I see Rapp moving to FS and Bishop taking SS. Hamlin would then be a quality back up.

Because you're the Jets.

By the conventional standards applied Hurtz was a worthy SB MVP as others have noted his numbers were more then good enough. But for anyone who watched the game the Eagles defense won the SB. Until they collapsed from exhaustion & despair the Chiefs D handled the Eagles O holding them to 13 points until late in the 3rd quarter. If anything Hurtz missed some throws and had a bad INT in the 1st half.

I think the NFL got what it wanted last night: they clearly showed that the conspiracy theory around their officiating is fake news and they reminded us that incompetence best explains the sucky reffing.

They were really going after Mahomes on some of the morning football shows. It was strange. Did you know Mahomes is "only" 3 - 2 as a Super Bowl starter? My experiences have been that 80% of the national NFL "experts" are vain, pompous know nothings whose opinions change on a dime in reaction to the last game. Sure Mahomes sucked yesterday. So what it happens. For the first time I'm seeing some of the Allen hate redirected by these people against Mahomes and it's weird.

I believe that in the end Bishop is going to be a very good, 10 years starter at Safety for the Bills. I suspect that if you put Bishop on the Eagles and DeJean on the Bills they would have had similar seasons.

On offense to if we're being honest. Outside of Allen, Dawkins & Brown who else on the Bills O would start over the Eagles starters? Maybe Shakir?

Another positive outcome from last nights SB was that given Barkley's good but not great performance Allen's MVP looks even more legit in the hindsight of the playoffs.

To be clear though the Eagles defensive game plan and execution was the deciding factor. 80% of last nights win can be directly attributed to the play of the Eagles D. In the first half and first possession of the 2nd half, when the game was decided, the Eagles D dominated the Chiefs forcing repeated 3 & outs, and 2 TO's that led directly to 14 points. The Eagles O had not exactly dominated the Chiefs and in fact was responsible for only 10 of the Eagles 24 points by midway through the 3rd quarter.

He didn't look special when the game was on the line tonight. Again a horrific performance by the Bills defense against a KC team with a deeply flawed offense should not be the final measuring stick of whether or not Worthy is "special".

I'm not sure I've ever seen a more misleading stat in a game then this one. Well wait Mahomes finished the game with a 95 QB rating. If you ever doubted the ability of garbage time performances to corrupt the stats this is it.

Worthy is ok but he was nowhere to be found when this game was still competitive. He didn't have a catch until the Eagles were leading 34 - 0.

Agree. Almost all the offense produced by Mahomes and Worthy was after the game was decided (Eagles up 34 - 0 late in the 3rd quarter). A great example of how garbage time can really impact the stats.

Damn I never thought I would say this but calling that TO was a bush league move by Andy Reid.

This thread is over and it is clear where the Bills problems lie and it is NOT on the offensive side of the ball.

How was Brady at this by his 7th season? Seems to me Brady relied on his Defense, running game and HOF coach in the first half of his career. And this was becasue of his superior mental abilities or his all world defense, coaching and 1st ballot HOF coach?

Fortunately for the sanity of the Universe it is not true.