ChronicAndKnuckles

He didn't have a bad game "for a rookie." He gained valuable experience and made some crucial throws. I just think you are being tough on him. Did he or did he not get the win? Is it or is it not his 4th game starting? What other QBs are you talking about? Fitzpatrick who's been in the league for 20 years? I don't care about stats, I care about wins. That's the bottom line.

Allens worst game? He made 2 critical passes on a game winning drive. The short dump offs that he's always been inaccurate with. The running game was working so Allen didn't have to put the last drive on his shoulders, but whos to say he wouldn't of made a long pass and got them into field goal range? It wasn't his best game, but most certaintly wasn't his worst. Come on, man. He managed the game well and won. Stats aren't everything.

How about a winning culture? Perennial playoff teams can attract free agents and at cheaper prices too

Exactly. People want to be pessimists, but why not be optimistic? We are coming off a playoff season with an upgraded defense and slightly downgraded offense, but with an improving talented QB. The whole AFC is tight right now and it's still early into the season. As I remember we got blown out a couple times last year too. Why can't I be excited? Why does it HAVE to be a rebuild?

We're 2-3 and only 1 game away from the top of the AFC East. Technically speaking. Edit: Sorry 2 games I guesss, but we've yet to play any division rivals. My point is we are competing.

I have no idea what the Eagles could offer because I don't have the knowledge of them like I do with the Bills. Maybe someone not on par with McCoy talent wise, but maybe someone younger and above average?

Terrell Owens build, hands of glue, could run the full route tree. We gave him Flutie, Holcomb, Jp Losman & company. What a waste.

Dude, McDermott got the Bills into the playoffs. What more do you want from him? And he did it with Tyrod Taylor as a QB. He could very well do it this year again if teams keep beating each other up. The defense is looking ferocious and that's the unit he decided to focus on first, he's a defensive minded coach. Give him a draft or 2, okay? Sheesh. Everyone keeps hating on a guy that broke an 18 year curse. I can't stand people like you.

In all honesty I think Moulds was the most talented of all, but that's a whole different topic and I don't want to derail this thread. FYI, I was being sarcastic about Josh Reed. He made some nice 3rd down catches in his day, but he's no where near the greatest nor the worst. As far as McCoy goes...If I was the Bills I would only do a player for player exchange unless they can somehow net a 2nd round pick (which they won't get for a 30 yr old RB unless they're truly that desperate) As many others have stated McCoy and Allen have a good relationship and you're taking away one of his few offensive threats and safety valves.

Only the greatest Wide Receiver to ever suit up in a Buffalo Bills uniform.

It's Tuesday. Did they sign him?

I would do it for an offensive lineman, but nothing more. Not even a Wide Receiver. Trading Shady would be a tremendous blow to this team leadership wise.

Thank God the Pegulas didn't sell out to Vegas.

hmmm and I wonder what the common denominator always is? Figure it out.

I'm pretty sure that's why they let Clements go to the 49ers was because they had McGee.

Seems like I've been reading the Rockpile Review for almost a decade. It's a tradition after every Bills game. Thank you

ereck's a wreck.

True, but if he keep playing at this rate then it would be wise to lock him up at least by his 3rd year. CB's that do it all don't come around every year and are not easily replaced. He reminds me a lot of Antoine Winfield.

All the hate put on Star and Trent Murphy. All those people should eat crow. This defense is slowly becoming elite.

WINNING gives Allen confidence and that's what a young QB needs. He needs to believe in himself so he can take that next step not to mention everything is not about Allen, we have 52 other players on this team. People may not realize it, but we are slowly building an elite defense. The Titans were no pushover at 3-1. I'm not talking playoffs just yet, but if this running game holds up and the defense keeps playing at the level they are generating turnovers (which was no fluke last year) then maybe it's a possibility.

He didn't need to pass for more yards because the running game was working so well. Why is this generation so obsessed with stats? Stats don't tell all. Allen also only had 19 attempts and a few crucial drops by the receivers. These aren't excuses, just facts. FYI Marcus Mariota only passed for 129 yards + turned the ball over like 3 times and he's a player that's been in the league since 2014 so what's his excuse?

This should've ended this thread.

McGee was the #2 at the time to Clements I believe? Tre White seems like a cornerstone player to me and is worth resigning to a mega deal. Based on those Bills Embedded clips I really like his personality. He doesn't seem to take himself super seriously. I do agree with what you're saying though. I believe Tre can be an exception.

Winfield played 8 seasons for minnesota and was a pro bowler for them 3 times.

I'm just saying historically Buffalo doesn't resign their number one CB's after their rookie deals.