I just watched the replay close up a few times, I am not sure that I would call that a muff. (skip to around :40 seconds for the replay) There was no juggling or bobbling, he just positioned the ball and off to the races.
I signed up last summer and have been glad I did... not just for Bills coverage ( I really like Fairburn's stories), but also they have pretty good Fantasy football coverage if you are into it. Jake Ciely and other writers provide great content throughout the season.