BillsFan130

Underrated one is EJ Gaines. He was really solid in 2017

Well when you imply he was on pace for over 1600 yards, you kind of are impying what his numbers would be. Or else, what's the purpose of saying he was on pace for over 1600 yards? Anyways, all good. My point is a 3 game sample size is wayyyy to early to say he is on pace for X amount of yards. I agree he is a good player, not denying that.

if you don't think goff is good, that's fair and I respect your opinion even though I respecfully disagree with it. I just don't understand why you are trying to prove that Goff gets carried by his team because of one game detroit won in which he was horrible. (That is cherry picking to try to prove something, as there are far more examples in which Goff has had to play great for Detroit to win) Every single good to great QB has had awful games where their team has still won. (Yes even Josh Allen as I showed)

You said exactly this: "He was on pace for over 1600 yards and 11 TDS". That's the definition of projecting numbers, sir.

I'm still not sure why you're drilled towards that one game where Goff played horrible and they won. Last season there were 4-5 examples where Goff needed to play great to get the win, and they did win, or his defence let him down in a shoot out. Josh Allens stats against Atlanta in January 2022: 11 for 26 for 120 yards, 0 tds and 3 INTS. But the Bills won by 2 touchdowns- So are we going to define one game as "the bills carry Josh Allen?"

I think he's a good player and I agree with that . But you can't project 3 games to 17 lol

But you're isolating one incident where Goff played crap and his team won in spite of him. What about his offence needing 34 points against GB to win by 3? Or 40 points against SF to win a one score game? Or losing with 42 points against the Bills?

Where are you getting these stats? lol. He wasn't on pace to getting over 1600 yards. 1. It's a 4 game sample size last year which is extremely small, so you can't project that to 17 games 2. He was on pace for 1200 yards, not 1600. 1200 is still very good, but you can't just take a small 4 game sample size and project it over 17 games. Keon Coleman had a 4 game stretch where he averaged 67.5 yards per game which would project to be around 1150 yards in a season lol

It's an interesting topic. Because what QBs can you win with, that make let's say 45 plus a year. Josh, Mahomes, Burrow, Lamar, Stafford , Hurts I think are the concrete 6. (Although Hurts contract is very back loaded) Then I would say you got maybes in Herbert, Baker and Goff Then there's a big drop from there. (Lawrence, Dak , Purdy etc.) I think your overall point is it's dumb to pay Purdy 45 a year (that was the real number that came out), cause you're not going to win with him at that number. Which I would agree with

Fair points- Although I used to say Tua is a system QB. And maybe he is- But he's absolutely vital to THAT system. Miamis offence goes to absolute s*** when Tua gets injured lol

This is interesting as I hear a lot of people say Purdy is a west coast Tua. I personally just don't see a ton of similiarities in their game If it's because they run a similar west coast offensive scheme that is based off of timing and accuracy? Ok sure But Purdy is WAY more off script than Tua- And has improved as a scrambler a lot over the last couple years. Tua= Better at accuracy and timing Purdy= Better at scrambling/going off script. JMO

Are you talking relative to contract? Like you would rather Fields at 20 million compared to those guys in the 50s? Or just straight up you think fields is better than them?

IMO: Pros: Accuracy, a good pre snap qb. (although I do think Shanny helps a ton with that) Cons: Poor arm strength, can't throw in inclement weather, poor decision making at times At best I think he is an average QB- JMO

SF had a team full of all pros. I think they legit had 5 all pros on their offence that year, which is absolutely ridiculous. Doesn't even include guys on the defensive side of the ball like Warner, Bosa etc

I think you mean, Have fun being "Mr irrelevant " now. Sorry I had to..