Jim Kelly lost Superbowls to Jeff Hostetler, Mark Rypien, and two to Troy Aikman in his 3 and fourth years. Jim Kelly never won a Superbowl. The Idea that because EJ doesn't fit your image of what a championship caliber quarterback looks like is simply your bias. And your bias is questionable because the object to which you compare EJ is not by definition a Championship caliber quarterback by Superbowl standards. If you said Troy Aikman, Montana, Flacco, Roethlisberger, Rypien, Hostetler, Young or any of the others who actually won one then I can see your point. I still don't believe in the "eyeball" test but at least it would be properly focused.