Not wrong. I was talking about how he finished the season, not the season in total. The guy caught fire and started producing like we all (well, maybe all) wanted him to. This is, despite, the injured foot.
Not all all. It just makes you look like an irrational 5th grader. If that's how you want to come across then have at it. Nobody will take anything you have to say seriously as long as you persist with this. There is a way of making the argument you're making smartly. You are not doing so.