Is it more risky than a botched long snap to the punter, a punt block, or a return? I don't have the stats but it's worth raising the question.
The reason people are asking about it is because it was different than the norm. Perhaps the norm is wrong - but when someone does something different I see nothing wrong with questioning it. Hell, I see nothing wrong with questioning the norm for that matter.
And I love the people in this thread who equate questioning with "complaining."