Yes, I would rather have the guy that has a 83 qb rating, won 16 games in his career, and started a playoff game than a guy with a 68.3 qb rating and won 2 games in his career. Is this ever a serious question?
and I know it won’t happen but in a perfect world, you should always be looking to upgrade your roster. Hoyer is better than Barkley and it’s not debatable.