Unless they are on the wall, I don’t wear anyone but current jerseys.
With that being said, I’ve never had a Jersey last more than two years with turnover. They are stupid expensive and ever since Nike took over, they are made super cheap.
I get why people don’t upgrade for that reason. But yes, I think it’s weird to support players not on the team that aren’t on the Wall. Kyle would be an exception because he will go up there.
I tried to find a good knock off site for jerseys as, for only $20, they are really well made.