newcam2012

In a perfect world yes. I like this train of thought. However, I think Coach McD has run it's course. The best way to find out is to let him call the D. If he's successful than he probably gets added run. If not, maybe the needed change will be quicker. It's a win win for the fans.

I really hope McD calls the plays. Thus far, he has been able to shield himself from much criticism via Fraizer. This will put him front and center. I suspect this will make or break his tenure with the Bills. We are about to find out how good he is. That's a good thing.

No. I think it would be ideal though. The offense needs innovation, weapons, protection, and change. I have little confidence in Dorsey. His offense had no identity or consistency. He never used plays in conjunction to set up other plays. It was a series of individual plays. I know the stats look very good. I'd credit Allen rather than Dorsey. Ben Johnson is one of the best offensive minds out there. He's getting the best out of Geoff. I know it won't happen.

I wouldn't mind seeing McD get demoted to DC. Bring in someone like Brian Callahan OC for Cinci or Ben Johnson OC for Lions. I would prefer Johnson. He is innovative, creative, and very smart. Think he would enhance Allen and others game.

As a fan, I don't view the Bills team as a "product." Perhaps you do? The team is so much more than that. It's a culture, the talk of the town, a sense of togetherness, Bills mafia and Bills babes. Fans who live out of town or state like myself proudly where my Bills gear win or lose. Many of us fans have invested so much into this team. Whether it be season tickets, traveling to games, having family outings and parties to watch the game, purchasing merchandise, etc... I myself as a fan of over 50 years is craving for a Lombardi trophy. Without a doubt tears of joy will be rolling down my face. I had to hold back tears after the Bills TD in KC with 13 seconds. Only to have my heart ripped out shortly thereafter. Of course, it's an exgerration but you get the point. I know it's only football but some take it seriously right or wrong. Allen is the pie in the sky. The Bills finally found the coveted franchise QB. The Bills should always be competitive based on how good he is. However, it's clear he needs help and can't do it all. The Bills franchise needs to find a way to help Allen succeed. With proper help he can certainly led this team to that Lombardi Trophy.

Nice post. It's really hard to project how any of those guys will do. Will they be immediate impact players? What's the learning curve? Can they develop into solid contributors? The Bills traditional move draft picks along slowly. Look at Elam and Shakir. Imho, it's going to be difficult to get immediate impact players from the draft positions the Bills hold. I believe they can pluck some talented guys that will become solid players down the road. Will that be enough? I want a Super Bowl appearance not an early playoff exit. The path to that seems slimmer as times passes. The Bills because of poor drafts, poor player development, poor coaching, and injuries have underpreformed the last few years. It's seemingly becoming a pattern. Good to great regular seasons with disappointing playoff endings. What's changing this year to think a different more positive result is likely next season? Same GM, same OC, same defensive scheme, and multiple holes to fill on both sides of the ball. We are left with hope perhaps false that Beane and McD can get the team over the hump. Past actions are often predictions of future results. History is studied to learn from previous mistakes. What will Von be like after his injury? Tre? Can Brown improve? Can Davis be that number 2 WR? Can the O and D line improve? Will the Bills be healthy? So many unanswered and unknowable questions. What's known is the Bills have failed to take steps forward as many of us thought they would. Excuses as for me are getting old and tiresome. I think we are nearing a point where something has to give. The team simply has to get over the hump soon.

He would have improved yhe Jets. However, Carr isn't a QB that I think the Bills fear. Carr isn't elite. He's a decent QB.

All easier said than done. (1) who is that RB? (2) Hard to trust the Bills staff when it comes to solidifying the Oline. Ford pick, Staffold sucked, Brown is not good and who knows if he will be. Bottom line is Beane and McD have had years to get it right. What makes you think they will get it right after years of incompetence? (3) Agree Bills need playmakers. Agree Davis had his chance. I don't wanna see a Davis WR2 rerun.

Why? Not all crimes are equal. Similarly, not all football mistakes are equal. What's so dumb about that?

Look at the Rams roster when they won it all. Look at the Chiefs roster this year. Mahomes played on one leg. Look at how bad Cinci's oline was when they went to the Super Bowl and when they hammered the Bills. Point being coaches, game plans, and schemes make a difference. Unexpected and inexperienced players step up. The last two seasons has shown us that the above mentioned is where the Bills fall miserably short. Until I see something different, I cannot have much faith that the Bills organization and team can stride to the next step.

I agree. I have no interest in Robinson unless we draft one with the 27th pick.

"IMO McD run his course, so has Beane. Could I be wrong? Of course. We'll see what this Draft brings, but given the results to date, the odds of one of our rookies stepping up to make a difference is nonexistent. It would be a first for Beane. As to McD, he won't have nearly to work with what he's had to date. White may be finished after his surgery, he certainly wasn't good when he returned this year. Poyer gone. Even drafting a WR at 27th isn't going to cut it. There hasn't been a WR drafted after 11th in either of the last two drafts that has put up starting #2 numbers or even close. Cinci's improving, KC's still KC, Miami and the Jets are breathing down our necks and each took one from us this past season. We can never rule NE out. Lawrence and Jax seem to be coming on and we couldn't beat them last time we played them when they sucked." Really well thought out and written. I concur with everything you said here. A sad and discouraging read but as accurate as could be. I really think it's time to move on from McD and Beane. They should move to a mediocre team that needs a build. They are great at turning around a losing organization. It's clear they can't get over the hump. McD consistently gets his butt waxed come playoff time. Besides Allen, Beane has way more misses than hits.

Spot on here.

Disagree and I know I'm likely in the minority. I know a lot depends on the board. Of course, if there's a glaring discrepancy then I can see the defensive pick. However, at pick 27 I tend to think there will be some good value on the offensive side. The Bills can always try to get a stop gap LB on the cheap. Too bad Bernard can't step in. He looks to be a wasted pick. Just my two cents.

We are all sinners my friend.

No to defense! Sorry man. The 27th pick has to be an offensive player. I wouldn't mind if every pick was offensive. I'm going into rhis year with the mindset of giving Allen protection and weapons. Let him cook. The defense falls where it falls. McD can try to get the best out of what he has. The organization has to change its mentality and focus. For too long it has concentrated on upgrading the defense. It hasn't worked come playoff time.

Let Edmunds go. Not worth that kind of money.

I'm no fan of Rodgers. I think he's likely on the decline. Mentally, I'm not sure how heart and mind is all in on playing football. 50 mil a year is a nice reward to keep playing. With that said, half a Rodgers is still better than what the Jets have. Probably, just as good or better than a limited and injury prone Tua.

Some mistakes are worse than others. There's a reason why the "13 second game" will go down as one of the greats. The 13 seconds is certainly part of why. It's kind of like comparing a manslaughter charge to a petty thief.

Generally speaking, I agree. However, it will depend on who Miami gets to replace Tua. For example, Aaron Rodgers with those WRs seemingly would be scary.

Thanks preacher! You got me...

Of course we want to be entertained. That is a pretty low standard. The team goal of the players, coaches, and management certainly isn't to entertain fans. It's a by product of winning. The goal is winning the Super bowl. First, let's try to get there. While, your feelings are yours, I doubt most Bills fans are truly satisfied with being entertained. Weak response!

Me too! Do you like disappointing playoff losses too? A Bills defense that can't stop a good quality playoff offense? A coaching staff that blows playoff games and clearly gets out coached? Whats the ultimate goal of the team Augie? Think macro not micro Not me. Im not timid about calling out foolish posts. Including yours Mr. Thurman. Great thing is I know I get the same back in return.

Fantastic synopsis! Pat yourself on the back for such a brutally honest assessment. I'm in totally agreement.

Most leaders I know take responsibility for their mistakes. The lone exception would be a narcisst. Clearly, McD doesn't meet that criteria. However, he has adequately ducked responsibility in the playoffs. Maybe that's acceptable? Not my style and it's certainly not authentic. I like to have the Buffalo media ask him the tough questions. For example, what do you plan to do to be more successful in the playoffs? How can you beat Cinci and KC in a playoff game? Why has your team have limited success in the last three years of the playoffs? Why should we believe you can led the team to the Super Bowl? This is where we miss Jerry Sullivan.