Weird thing about the Coleman pick is that everybody was shocked because he was seen as limited and maybe a 3rd or 4th round talent.
By taking him where he did, Beane was basically saying, we see something no one else sees in Coleman, you'll all see.
And then he turns into exactly the limited player everybody said he would be, even with a ton of forced targets to his supposed strength, jump balls.
Except even worse, because his motivation seems completely sapped--maybe from being put in a position where he can't succeed.