
SoTier
Community Member-
Posts
5,769 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by SoTier
-
The Jets have talent but they are a deeply dysfunctional franchise. They looked like a real team in their latest win, but the real test comes when things go south. Whether you call it culture or team spirit or whatever, that connection among team members (both players and coaches) that enables teams like the Bills or Chiefs or Lions to face adversity with an all-for-one mentality is missing in the Jets where it seems that are other agendas at play. Not only have numerous media analysts noticed this, but some players have also mentioned it, most surprisingly newcomer Davante Adams (or maybe not surprisingly since Rodgers hinted at the same thing earlier). I can't see a team that deeply divided winning 6 or 7 games in the last half of the season.
-
The Jets are going to remain the Jests as long as Woody Johnson owns them. The Jets haven't drafted a competent QB since they took Chad Pennington in the first round of the 2000 draft. What makes you think they'll find one in the 2025 draft? They have less draft capital for 2025 because of the pick(s) they gave up to get Adams. Expecting to get three starting caliber players, including a franchise QB and an OT, out of one draft with only a single first round pick is unrealistic for any team, but especially for a team with an owner who thinks he's a football expert with a track record that proves he isn't. Because of Rodgers' contract the next 2 years as well as the money they've committed to Rodgers' pals, they probably can't afford to pay even a retread QB unless he's willing to play near the league veteran minimum. Why is the world would Ben Johnson have any interest in coaching the Jests? Rodgers' legacy is an albatross weighing down the Jests' future, but Woody Johnson has been and will continue to be a millstone on the Jests' future.
-
That Johnson is a great coordinator doesn't mean that he will make a great HC. Mike McDaniel was the "hot" OC, but his tenure as Fish HC has not been all that successful. Steve Spagnulo is a great DC but he failed spectacularly as a HC in St Louis (10 wins in 3 seasons) despite his successful stint as DC for the Giants. None of Belichick's coordinators have turned out to be even good HCs.
-
ROTFLMAO. Obviously you weren't a Bills fan between 2000 and 2016. I guarantee you that there are a whole lot worse situations for a fan than having your team be a serious championship contender every year. And for the record, Matthew Stafford never won a playoff game in his 11 seasons with Detroit, and only had 4 winning seasons. In his last season in GB, Aaron Wilson failed to lead the Packers to the playoffs despite playing a full season. Thinking that the Bills are guaranteed winning seasons because they have Allen is just plain ignorance.
-
Sad but true.
-
How exactly does a team fire a HC and NOT "blow things up"???? A new HC is going to bring his own philosophy and his own people, and that means that a significant number of the current players are not going "fit" what the new coaching regime wants ... and a bad scheme fit can make an All Pro look pretty ordinary. Allen could suffer if he was in an offense like those in San Francisco and Miami which wouldn't fit his playing style all that well. Your "theory" isn't a theory at all. It's simply your belief -- or more precisely, your prejudice. You have no real proof and no way to actually acquire proof because coaching success is dependent on so many other factors, including team ownership and team management. Bill Belichick was fired from his first head coaching stint in Cleveland in the 1990s because he didn't win enough. Andy Reid was run out of Philly because he didn't get to the Super Bowl enough.
-
Guaranteed that there will complainers even after a Bills Super Bowl win.
-
You want to fire McDermott to hire Vrabel????? Seriously??? 🤣 Belichick disciples have been notably unimpressive as Head Coaches at best, so that's NOT a point in his favor. In his 6 seasons as HC in Tennessee, Vrabel has a record of 54-45. Three of his teams made the playoffs. His playoff record is 2 wins, 3 losses with the 2 wins in the same season -- wild card and divisional wins, which isn't any better than McDermott's playoff record. The history of the NFL is littered with "hot" OCs (and DCs, too) who failed miserably as HCs. As for "wasting Josh Allen" by not making conference championships that's bull manure. Playing in the playoffs every season isn't "wasting" a QB's talent because making the playoffs in the NFL is incredibly hard --especially when a QB is at the mercy of mercurial ownership as well as front offices and coaching staffs of questionable quality so their opportunities are extremely limited. Ask Matthew Stafford. He played for the Lions for 11 seasons and made the playoffs 3 times and never won a single playoff game. As for your question, "btw, now that I answered your questions. Who do you have as a HC who took 7+ years with his QB to win a Super Bowl?", as the disclaimers on personal injury lawyers' ads always says, "prior results don't guarantee future outcomes".
-
Both the NFL's pension and health care provisions are paid for by the NFL and were negotiated with the NFLPA. Under the 2020 CBA, the NFL currently contributes $2 billion to player benefits. Player fines go into a fund to help out players who may have extraordinary medical bills, and that, too, was negotiated.
-
My guess is that it's a percentage of his salary.
-
Even if Von doesn't help the Bills get to the SB, his was the better signing because the Bills were actually trying to build a SB team. A player can't help getting hurt. The Bills signed Mario Williams simply to put butts in the seats. They needed a big name to once again con fans into supporting a team that always put profit ahead of winning during Russ Brandon's reign. Williams played for the Bills from 2012 through 2015, making All Pro in 2013 and 2014, but his success was personal because the cast around him lacked talent. His HCs were Chan Gailey, Doug Marrone, and Rex Ryan. The QBs for the Bills were Ryan Fitzpatrick, EJ Manuel, Kyle Orton, and Tyrod Taylor. The Bills went 6-10, 6-10, 9-7, and 8-8 and never made the playoffs with Williams on the team.
-
The problem isn't the graph. If you wish to evaluate the Bills' WR separation after the Amari Cooper trade, then use the graph of the Bills' WR separation data from weeks 1-6 and the same graph with data for weeks 7-8. Any type of graph or table based on data from weeks 1-8 won't tell you what you're trying to find out. Sure-handedness >>> separation.
-
What does Elam and a pick get you in this market?
SoTier replied to FireChans's topic in The Stadium Wall
Some people do not seem to grasp the concept of depth, especially for a playoff contender. -
What does Elam and a pick get you in this market?
SoTier replied to FireChans's topic in The Stadium Wall
I'm counting the hours to the NFL trade deadline ... -
Khalil Mack trade - what would it take?
SoTier replied to MiracleAtRich1393's topic in The Stadium Wall
Despite Mack's 17 sacks last season, he didn't seem to have a significant impact on the Chargers defense. The Chargers won only 5 games last season. Their defense ranked 31st in passing yards allowed and 29th in YPA allowed. IOW, he put up big meaningless stats. Pass. -
Absolutely spot on. I think he knows where Woody Johnson has buried his skeletons. ... led by backup QB Jacoby Brissette!
-
Would any reasonable owner, including Jerry Jones, undermine his GM and HC by giving a player control of personnel? Giving your great QB input on personnel is one thing, but the situation in NY is unprecedented.
-
It's a reminder that fans should be careful about what they wish for because they might get it. The Pegulas hit the jackpot when they hired Beane who had never been a GM before. They might not be so lucky next time, particularly if they were to "clean house" in the front office (and likely coaching staff) by firing Beane. I disagree. The problem with the Jests is owner Woody Johnson. For most of his quarter century of ownership of the Jests, the team has sucked. In the early 2000s, the Jests had some decent teams with talent left from the previous regime (Bill Parcells). They also had a couple of good seasons under Rex Ryan, but they've had only 1 winning season in the last 13 years. The last even moderately successful QB the Jests drafted and developed was Chad Pennington whom they kicked to the curb for Brett Favre in 2007 -- and like Geno and Darnold, went on to play pretty well for the Dolphins for a couple of years. Johnson's GMs (Bradway, Tannenbaum, Idzik, Maccagnan, and Douglas) have spent a fortune of draft capital on QBs with very little success ... at least for the Jests. Hopefully, Johnson never sells the team ... and lives a few more decades.
-
Ravens lost.
-
Sam Darnold and other QB resurrections
SoTier replied to ChronicAndKnuckles's topic in The Stadium Wall
How can an 11th round (#285) round pick ever be a bust? -
I think that the media types are assuming that Cooper is a part-season rental, but my guess is that it's really a try out to see if he fits the Bills and he wants to be a Bill in 2025. I would love to have Myles Garrett on the Bills but I don't think it happens even if Cleveland was interested in dealing him, which I'm not sure they are.
-
Sam Darnold and other QB resurrections
SoTier replied to ChronicAndKnuckles's topic in The Stadium Wall
Flutie was never a bust. He chose to play in the CFL because he realized he'd never get a chance in the NFL because he was considered too small. His situation was much like Warren Moon who also chose the CFL because he didn't want to play any position but QB and knew he wouldn't get that chance. Both had great careers in the CFL before coming into the NFL and proving themselves. Absolutely true. Under the control of the Bills' Evil Genius Russ Brandon, the Bills offensive coaching staff was sketchy at best when they drafted Allen. The Bills "QB coach" in 2018 was a guy who hadn't actually coached QBs in 20 years, and only did that for a year on the college level. Brandon was fired in May, 2018, and Beane was given full GM powers. After the 2018 season, all of the offensive coaches except Daboll were fired and Ken Dorsey was hired as Allen's QB coach. The rest, as they say, is history but it could have been very different for Allen, too. Smith, Baker and Darnold all were drafted by substandard, perhaps even dysfunctional, organizations. Hell, the Jests under Woody Johnson, can't even put together a good team with one of the greatest QBs playing for them. What chance did Smith and Darnold really have with them? Once a high round QB fails for his original team, he's generally relegated to backup status. Smith, Baker, and Darnold all spent time as backups under great coaches with excellent assistants (Carroll, McVay and Shanihan) and emerged as better QBs for it. Once again, coaching matters. -
Great name for a WR.
-
FYI GMFB just interviewed the Bills' Ray Davis. It was maybe 5 minutes or so. You can probably catch it again at 10:40-10:45 and 12:40-12:45
-
2018 QB draft and passer rating rankings this season
SoTier replied to dave mcbride's topic in The Stadium Wall
You may be right about Darnold but Mayfield has always been at least a decent starter. He was Rookie of the Year in 2018, and he played pretty well in Cleveland, including 2021 when he played hurt most of the season. The Browns kicked him to the curb in order to get Watson. He spent part of 2022 in Carolina and the rest with the Rams (replacing Stafford who was injured). In Tampa, he's shown again that he's a really good QB.