oldmanfan

Let's calm down a bit. Milano is an All Pro caliber player, and Williams is filling his spot. Bernard is filling Edmund's spot and I think that's a wash at minimum.

Not good

The OP does these to draw attention to himself.

Yep. Shorter route success would also open up the deeper routes for Gabe. And Diggs will get his no matter what- he’s that good.

I think both Kincaid and Knox will have very good careers. It really comes down to Josh spreading the ball around and Dorsey setting good route combos. We saw how well it can work in the three blowout games this season.

We need that person, Kincaid could certainly be that person, but will Josh consistently make the throw to that person?

True. Those thinking a Kincaid might be as good as two first ballot HOF TEs set themselves up for disappointment

38-10 Bills. Belicheat will try to take away Diggs, and Josh and Dorsey will get back to spreading the ball around like they did in the 3 blowouts. And they have nothing on offense.

I thought you were talking about Josh McDaniels. That would be hilarious if you think he’s better than McD. But I think you refer to Mike McDaniel, who one could make an argument for. Certainly has done a lot with that offense, but we’ll see how the rest of this season goes.

Mc Daniel? Funniest thing I've read in a long time.

Doug Williams

That is simply not true if one actually watches games. He runs plenty of intermediate out routes.

Jim Plunkett.

Good luck

What a moron.

Allen is one of the best players the Bills have ever had. He is to me the most talented QB in the league. He has won a ton of games for the Bills. But he lost the Jets game because he stunk. He said so himself. As HC McD is ultimately responsible for the team’s play. When they lose he has to answer for it. But when they win he deserves credit for it as well. Is this really that hard to understand?

The 13 second game? Dumb, Frazier should have had the D knock WRs down and McD should have overruled him. I’ve already said that. Jets? Our star QB threw up on himself the entire second half. Jags? Again the offense didn’t play well. Should we be 6-0? Yes. All on McD? Because he’s HC theoretically yes. In actuality certainly not the Jets game. And the 3 blowouts. Is he responsible for wiping out a really hot Fish team? Don’t worry, I suspect I know your answer.

If true he shouldn’t be there. It’s not true of course but whatever makes you happy.

Then quit using the termZ You know this how?

Wake me up when someone can define # 2 WR.

If you hire a guy that does not win, it costs you seasons. McD gets you to the playoffs every year. He wins. That gives you a shot. But as I said if he starts to slide backward or starts losing the locker room you make a change. I would also add managing the staff. It was a smart move in my opinion to jettison Frazier and take over the D. The D D s playing much better again IMHO. He may need to look at OC if the struggles continue. But since Josh wanted Dorsey from all accounts that would be an interesting call.

As a guy that has been a fan since opening day 1960 I have the AFL championships. But I feel as you do. It takes talent, and some luck to break your way at the right time.

You keep a HC that get you in the playoffs and give you a legitimate shot. If he starts losing or starts losing the locker room you make a change. That’s my philosophy. Obviously not yours.

No you haven’t. Most of your examples the guys did not win Lombardis. If I’m reading you right you’re saying McAfoo replacing Coughlin is proof of your thesis because he got Eli to 11-5 after a few losing seasons. If that’s your proof it’s laughable.

And as far as HC go it’s magnified. You mention Johnson. He’ll be the hot commodity this coming off season. But does he have what it takes to be a HC? Only one way to find out and if you’re wrong you cost your team years.