oldmanfan

I think it's hard to pick a best because the different positions require different talents and such, but the 4 most talented guys to ever wear a Bills uni to me are Bruce, OJ, Josh, and Cookie.

Matchups. They best matchups were with the RBs and TEs so they took them.

They desperately need a senior guy on this team to come in, wear the C, and shake the locker room to the core. I watched the Rangers game and the degree of softness in this team is unbelievable.

Whatever. Football is the ultimate team game but you don’t think anyone but Josh has talent on this team. Live in your bubble.

Goff is top 5 I’d say. Josh and Mahomes, Burrow then Goff is up there.

And you don’t think Bills fans recognize how great it is to have Josh? As I said, you’re nuts.

Their offense was also great today. Come on. This was shoot out between two great offenses playing injury ravaged defenses.

You’re nuts at this point. And offense in other games depends on the game, the players, the matchups, and a myriad of other variables.

Bills fans take Josh for granted. Sure. Now I’ve heard it all.

I will state it again: Josh is phenomenal. But that doesn’t mean some of the great plays made by teammates should somehow be downgraded.

And if Goff wasn’t for the Lions it’s not even close.

Milano has been a warrior and a superb player for the Bills. But injuries and age seem to be taking their toll.

And the same can be said for Mahomes as one example. Maybe Goff too considering how beat up their D is. Sure. Right. You had a game here where the two best offenses in the league played two injury ravaged defenses. I would have preferred we not play zone in the fourth quarter but am not surprised they came back

Brady called a helluva game and the D played well the first half. If you could stop your McD hate for one second you’d see that.

Today was to get an IV for cramping?

All you’re doing here is setting up false comparisons based on single plays. Goff ran around today and made some great plays off script as did Josh. The NFL is full of extraordinarily talented athletes and we saw a bunch of them make great plays today. Is Josh perhaps the most physically talented? I’d say yes. But that doesn’t mean the great plays made by teammates are somehow tarnished because of that. Then do so

That’s fair.

You are making a bizarre false comparison.

Because Josh is great. And Brady called a great play. And Johnson ran it and made a great catch. What is it so damn difficult to recognize that? Josh is a phenomenal QB having a phenomenal year - does that mean the contributions of others need to be ignored or denigrated?

Normal defenses aren’t missing around half their starters.

No class then. Figured.

What about the great catches from Johnson and Knox and Kincaid?

Yeah that one, the one that had a lot of guys hurt like we did.

Josh is phenomenal. Unquestionably the MVP. Of course we’re dependent on him as is all teams with talented QBs. The words I just used. So disrespecting? Get over yourself and your junk. Like challenging me to a bet that the Lions would score their first drive of the second half then welching on it. Have some class and send the $100 to Oishei..

Did you look at the other D on the field tonight?