I think once you're out of the top 5, maybe 10, just getting a solid contributor for a few years would be a successful pick. I thought he played well last season and I thought he looked very good in the first preseason game. If he plays well this season, that's a B grade. I doubt the Bills sign him because of the cost of a 2nd contract, but Shaq will almost definitely be in the league a few more years barring some drastic change in his game or injury.