Wayne Cubed

This. I'll never understand people who think any other position isn't a gamble. Guess what? If you you pick a different position at #8 (LB, DL, WR, CB) the chances of them succeeding in the NFL are still the same if you pick a QB. It's still the same risk. What if the Bills do go with a WR at #8 and Geno Smith goes next pick to the Jets. Then the WR flops and Geno goes on to have a productive career. Was it wise to wait then? The draft is a crap shoot.

Huh? Isn't qualified at all? As already mentioned... Bucky Brooks played in the NFL for 5 years, he then was a scout for Seahawks for 3 years. Why isn't he qualified? A team ACTUALLY paid him to make decisions/recommendations on players. Greg Cosell, although widely thought of as a good analyst by media pundits, has NEVER worked for or scouted or been paid for an opinion by an NFL team. He's never played football at a professional level. Saying that, he is certainly been looking at film for a very long time, so his opinion does merit some weight. And thats the trooth...

Supposedly they are doing these workouts plus bringing them in for predraft visits. And these workouts aren't happening at the Bills facility, so they will get to see the player twice.

I have to agree with this as well. Not sure what the big deal is... As SJBF posted from Jeff Fisher, just lower the shoulder if you want to hit. Turn your shoulder into the hit. The game has gotten to the point where the helmet itself is used as a weapon.

Apparenlty you do not understand a couple things, statistics being one, decimals and averages being the other. When a QB is throwing 500+ balls the diference between 6.7 and 7.2 is huge. Even if RF went an extra 20-20 in a game averaging 10 yards a throw, that's 200 more yards WITHOUT an incompletion, his YPA still wouldn't come to what Bree's YPA was. RF would be at 7.0 YPA. But seeing as RF is only a 60% thrower, lets extrapolate that a bit. Meaning out of 20 balls he might complete 12. So for him to get to 20 balls on an average of 10 yards a completion, he would go 20-33. And if we add that to his totals, his YPA only comes up to 6.8. See where I'm going here? RF would have had to play out of his mind to raise his YPA by a .5. So, no, there numbers aren't close.

Yea, Nassib was there in 2008 and was red-shirted in favor of Paulus.

I think you could also throw into the mix the fact that Marrone/Hackett are basically getting another chance to select/recruit a QB to run there offense. Would they choose Nassib if given a second chance? Or do they see other Qb's with skills they desire? With the NFL draft they are getting a chance at supposedly the best and only competing with 31 other teams. As opposed to college recruitment where they were competing against other, power house programs, where the ultimate say is left up to the player.

Add to that, in those truly windy or snowy conditions, what do teams generally do? They hand the ball off and grind it out in the running game. I never understood the weather excuse...

You assume that Marrone thinks he's a good one... Maybe he doesn't. Truth is you can't say whether he thinks he's good or bad. That's something I'm sure Marrone will keep within the organization.

This. You wouldn't bet your career on player from college, just because he knew your system. I think it would be career suicide. You take the player you believe to be the "answer."

Great, I would happen a guess it was still dumbed down a bit.

If the Bills and Marrone decide to go this route iy would the biggest mistake ever made by a Head Coach. Why would you bring in a offense built for the likes of college football, with the same QB and expect it to succeed? You'd have to change it up at least a little bit and suprise people. Yea maybe you bring pieces of it, but NFL defenses would eat a college offense up, especially the one Syracuse ran.

Fair enough.

Not that your not entitled to your opinion but as I read through some scouting reports on him I'd say he has concerns. - decision making - accuracy - struggles to work through progressions - didn't play we'll against good defenses - not a natural passer

Looks like Arizona did not attend the WVU pro day. It will be telling if they go to Barkley's/USC. Although at this stage in the game every team is sending out a lot of misdirection.

In any case the Bills were the first team mentioned by Smith for a pre-draft visit. “I’ve got something coming up with the Bills on the 22nd. As of right now I would expect between 10 to 12 (pre-draft visits), maybe more."

I just poo'd

Whoa, whoa. No need to come in here and throw around facts.

Hey I'm right there with you, I was laying the sarcasm on pretty thick...

Didn't you know it was Nassib himself who beat Geno. Obviously. NO one else on the Syracuse team contributed to the win. Further more no one on WV contributed to the loss, certainly not the defense.

Ha, Love it. But, but, but, there will be some amazing talent in the second round for QB.

Like what the Redskins did. I think people worry that Geno isn't RGIII, in terms of talent.

Some quotes about Geno on his workout; "Smith showed lots of balance and great accuracy on the move, while hiting targets 25 yards plus down the field" "his downfield touch and accuracy was impressive. Lots of zip on the ball and balance throughout his compact release" sorry on my phone, can 't link to the article

And yet another thread...

Soooo besides the players the Bills have drafted, the team is filled by a bunch of crazies?