OldTimer1960

Trying to guess who their guy would be. For as lauded as this receiver class is, I’m not terribly excited about the guys left.

Justin Shorter was a top WR recruit coming from H.S. and he was picked late in the 5th round. I don’t like Franklin’s route running, contested catches ability or ability to play strong on the boundary. FWIW, Greg Cosell didn’t exactly articulate a ringing endorsement today on Buffalobills.com

In my opinion, Coleman would be a pretty bad pick. What would he help besides maybe a jump ball or 2? Definitely not explosive (at least speed and quickness). Not a deep threat nor a good technical route runner. What do you see in Polk that you like? I get that he is the try-hard guy and is good at contested catches, but I don’t see speed or quickness evident in his play. He can make a team and maybe be a starting receiver, but I don’t see more than an average NFL player.

I agree that they seem to really like him. I would avoid AD Mitchell - too many reports of character/effort issues for my taste. I don’t like Keon Coleman at any spot in round 2. I do like Ladd McConkey, but I acknowledge that he has some size/durability risk and probably isn’t a deep threat in spite of his 4.39 40. Polk and Baker are interesting, but not until late round 2 or later. Of course, these are just my fan opinions.

What queen are you referring to?

Where do the reputable analysts rate Franklin? Not very high. What eye test did he pass. I’ve watched multiple games of his and all of his combine on field work. I see a very thin guy who is fast, but not ultra fast and doesn’t have instant acceleration as evidenced by his poor 10yd split in the 40. His hands are pretty small and he is not strong enough tobexcel at contested catches. The combine was poor with his inability to run anything close to a straight line in the gauntlet drill and him falling running routes against air. Now, clearly he produced big plays in college, but the PAC 12 isn’t exactly known for their defense. I think he can be a complementary receiver in the NFL, but I am not expecting a star and in spite of his good speed I think he will struggle as a deep threat due to his lack of strength preventing fighting for contested catches. If the Bills pick him, I will hope that I am wrong about him, but he would not be my pick.

I think they like Franklin, but I have a bad feeling that he isn’t as good as the Bills apparently think he is.

I guess we will see, but I’ll be very surprised if they take Mitchell.

That’s not my point. I am arguing that if they really liked any the WR they would have taken one at 28 or 32. The flip side would be that they liked so many equally that they felt they could trade down. Im just guessing, but based on Beane’s comment that they will get call for pick 33, I think he is looking to trade down again- likely because they aren’t crazy about any of the remaining receivers.

I just think that his talent would have dictated he go round 1 if he didn’t have rumored concerns about effort/taking coaching.

I’m afraid you’re right. Agree, better than Coleman, but I don’t like Franklin until late 2nd or later. I just don’t see it with him. I don’t think he is physical enough to be a strong deep threat.

That would be very disappointing.

I think that will be difficult given his frame.

If they wanted Mitchell, they would have taken him at 32 - the extra 5th would not have swayed him. Franklin and Coleman - no thanks Baker and Polk would be huge reaches before back end of round 2.

McConkey is the best receiver left, in my opinion. I think if they were going to take Mitchell, they would have done so already. I understand that McConkey isn’t an X, but if it isn’t him it’s another position in my opinion.

Franklin doesn’t interest me early in round 2. I’m not super keen on trading for an expensive vet like Aiyuk, but at least he isn’t super old - don’t know how they fit him under the cap this year though.

I think you’re right and I will be very disappointed if that’s where they go.

Please not Franklin unless it’s late round 2.

I don’t really have a guess other than that they didn’t really like the WRs as much as the general consensus does. I think if they liked Mitchell they would have picked him already. I would take McConkey here, but I have a sinking feeling that they are going to take Franklin.

Top of 5th round pick for 1 spot down. Is that 4 5th round picks now?

Bills out

Wow

I can believe that and would kind of like that, depending how far down they would go.

There will be a trade up or two in coming rounds.

That lit the fuse here on the board. Wait until we see who they take at 32