paulmm3

Here's the answer to the comp pick question

I watched Cole Bishop at Utah and liked him a lot and hoped he'd look a little better right at the beginning of his career. But also he's 21 years old and still learning.

I expect it will take Amari a little while to learn the playbook. WR is one of the harder positions to be traded and learn a new system at. But hopefully getting him this early he'll have enough time to learn and help us later in the season.

Glad the Bills are bringing in kickers. I think there's almost no way the FO cuts Bass and signs one of these guys, but even in that case it's good to give Bass competition.

Maybe a little bit, but who cares? Every commentator has teams they seem to like more and less

3rd round pick going the other way. Contract up at the end of this season

I don't think the organization is going to blame Bass too much for last night since Zuerlein also missed two easy kicks last night. I agree that Bass sucks and I'd like a new kicker though, don't get me wrong.

Just weak in the middle. Bad safety play. Damar has to go. Dorian Williams is better at pass coverage than run D and worse than Milano overall. Ed Oliver is better at pass rushing than run D. Bernard hasn't been great at run defense either when he's been in.

Wtf is this bs personal foul is this not a contact sport?

Wtf is that call

Watching live I thought the XP was missed and it seemed like some others on the game thread did too

Bass again

No

I also thought that XP was missed

3 receptions in 5 games but also only 5 targets in 5 games. He's obviously overpaid compared to his production. But it seems more an issue of getting him involved than what he does with his targets. That's coaching. If we were going to make any changes - and I'm not sure we need to make changes at 3-2 - I would say fire McDermott and bring in Belichick. Shakir, Knox, and Kincaid may be our 3 best receiving options. Maybe Coleman. But Belichick had success with Hernandez, Gronk, and Welker. Knox, Kincaid, and Shakir are obviously not as good players but could be used similarly.

We all remember from the combine that Coleman has a slow 40 time (20th percentile) and know looking at him he's not that fast. He got those Kelvin Benjamin comparisons. But what people don't talk about as much and that Coleman has but Kelvin Benjamin didn't is excellent plant-and-push explosiveness for one step. Coleman tested about 80th percentile broad jump at the combine (Benjamin was 20th percentile in this one). I think I've seen this play out in games too. Coleman isn't going to beat people for pace, but in terms of "plant and explode towards the ball" he's pretty darn good at it.

I am all for making changes in how the offensive and defensive plays are called.

There could be some immediate cause of Saleh getting fired, or it could be the 20-36 record.

I'm a physician, this guy is also a physician but a busybody who needs to keep his opinions based on reviewing TV footage to himself.

Part of the reason the passing game was bad was the bad first down running game forced us into lots of obvious long passing downs. More a criticism of offensive playcalling than James Cook who did have some good runs.

I'm most upset with McD for not challenging on that Kincaid catch in the first half but McD did a lot wrong today

How many first downs were 0-2 yard runs to James Cook? Like 2/3 of the time?

That was one of the worst no challenge decisions I've ever seen

Wtf not challenging that was a catch. Fire McDermott hire Belichick

Should be a late hit on Josh personal foul there