Not at all,it would be a brilliant move if they have any confidence in Luck. It's obvious the Colts have many problems in all areas and need to revamp the whole team. Trade the still useful Manning for a boatload of established players and draft picks[remember Herschel Walker?] Build a solid team around Luck. Some risk, but whats the alternative? Best case, play Manning and MAYBE go 8-8. Worst case Manning gets hurt early on and drops to zero trade value. Now you have Luck and no players.