GaryPinC

I didn't know that about Day and Kelly, thanks, yeah totally could play into it. I look at Knowles' age vs Day and quite honestly I feel the offense somewhat underperformed especially and until after the Michigan debacle so given everything here I could see Knowles feeling he was unfairly singled out. Good point about Franklin, next year will be telling, a lot of guys coming back to make a run at it. I also think Allar is too much like Christian Hackenberg between the ears, so I fear that will sabotage things. Franklin's not a bad recruiter and seems to foster a family atmosphere but has always felt like a slimy used car salesman from the sticks. Obviously his lousy decision making in big games too, but unfortunately he seems to stay in the good graces of his superiors. Knowles may be angling, just not sure he's HC material at this point. Oh well, it'll all make for good social cannon fodder drama in the B1G!

No, why would anyone be that naive? Do you believe replacing him or them will only result in a downgrading of our capabilities? My point is that Josh is mid career and what we have been doing has only gotten us to a certain level. I believe the current FO needs to tweak their approach a bit to help overcome this wall. But, if they won't, we are approaching a point where different leadership may be required to give a different result. You don't have to even like basketball to look at what's happening to the Cleveland Cavaliers. Their first year, experienced coach was targeted and brought in to get them to the next level with the same talent and even now it's obvious how much more formidable they are compared to the last several years. Their fired coach got hired right away to lead the floundering Detroit Pistons and he's having success also. For whatever reason though, he hit his ceiling with the Cavs and a tough but correct decision was made.

They do, and certainly I'm not privy to the inner workings of a coaching staff. I have to believe McDermott is a guiding hand with the game plans where he gives parameters and reviews them. I also expect at critical points in games he will weigh in if he feels strongly about a situation. I believe this because Brady and Babich are most likely not going to be here long term and I expect our head coach to pass along the hard earned playoff wisdom and set the tone and address any details he feels important in the game plan. That makes the most sense and as you mention, he is ultimately responsible.

I also saw that Ryan Day got more involved with the D (sitting in meetings) after the Oregon loss including a pointed discussion with Knowles. Who knows about the LJ thing so I'm thinking an overall perceived trust/disrespect issue drove him out. Glad to have him at PSU but not happy if it prolongs Franklin's career here. With PSU loading up for next year it'll be interesting to see if Knowles' complex system helps or hurts their chances.

Quite frankly who to choose would be up to Beane and/or an outside consultant if needed. You want a coach who will tweak the philosophy without changing the culture. But we know what we would need in a new coach. That's a huge advantage in a search and certainly those types of coaches would be attracted to this job. But yes I agree another year for McD.

Yep, he did a great job at what he does best, pulling a team together and executing his system. That's not what I'm talking about, here's what I'm talking about: https://nypost.com/2025/01/27/sports/the-sean-mcdermott-decisions-that-burned-bills-in-crushing-afc-championship-game-setback/ Coach McD addressing the failed tush pushes: “It’s been our best play all year at one or inside of one yard. We won some of those, but … they were doing a good job,” McDermott said. “I thought overall, maybe we could have disguised it, maybe not, but at the end of the day we have confidence in Josh and our offensive line to get those and they’ve been getting them all year.” Until he changes this "rely only on the system" mindset in the playoffs, we will continue to fail in the biggest moments. Even worse, how are you going to disguise the push? He simply needs to open his mind and think differently in the playoffs. I'm not saying we abandon the sneaks/push. I'm saying McD needs to realize playoffs mean top coaches and top talent. That means you better have backup plans, different looks, different wrinkles to things we've put consistently on tape all year. Self scout, especially in regards to the strengths of our opponent, ie. what are they likely to stop us from doing? Same thing on defense with Mahomes sweep right. They did it all year. No specific plan for that, trusted the system and it failed. Again. Open your mind McDermott. Realize when and where your system needs adjustments or changes and be prepared. Even if only for one game. The big games.

Yes! After 7 seasons of Josh Allen let's keep on the same exact path doing the same exact things and keep telling our players and fans to trust it. We'll keep glorifying our regular season successes instead of addressing the hard questions to push for postseason success.

Is it time to move on from McDermott? Not yet. But what is imperative is that he come up with a new focus and new direction, best on defense I think. "Trust the Process" is clearly flawed, that will eat away at the culture if unchanged. McDermott and Beane have some serious work to do to refocus this team. You can’t expect the team to keep buying into something that's not working well enough.

Yeah, I have feeling they don't practice low balls as much as they should, but understandable as less are thrown there. Still, he knows how to do it. Maybe he just misjudged it.

It was below the waist and I'd say at knee or thigh level so it wasn't like he was trying to pick it off the turf. Problem is he tried to arm/basket catch it instead of using his hands. He was in position because it was a long pass so he could track it. Very catchable ball that should have been caught. Can't agree with you that he made some massive adjustment or that it was hard to catch for a pro football player.

I'm just praying for some kind of video and Bills Mafia will donate to Vrabel's charity of choice.

😂 No, your ignorance hurts. Josh can't run downfield and catch his own throws nor play defense. He's the best quarterback this franchise has ever seen and may ever see. Jim Kelly readily admits Allen is more talented than him. This roster just doesn't have enough talent and dynamic coaching.

I wouldn't say he's had just about enough but agree it has to be creeping into his brain. No QB can play absolutely perfect, but Josh is at the top of his game and so at some point he's going to realize the FO isn't good enough if things don't change.

Yep, that's on coaching. We are an established team and you can't be content to rest on that. Extra effort to details of KC must be made if we want to beat them.

This is the most ignorant thing I've ever seen in a football discussion. I have no words other than I hope you stop being a Bills fan.

The answer is we need more dynamic coaching with better attention to details coming in and we need to tweak our defensive system (especially the DL) and get the personnel needed. We were right there except for a botched reception. Josh sees all and is at the top of his game. McDermott needs to realize where and why we got outcoached and make changes. But this is how it's going to be competing with Lamar and Mahomes every year. Coaches and FO need to up their game. I would say clearly you're not an eternal optimist and that's ok. Walk away if you must or take some tiime and perspective to rediscover your optimism. Earning a Superbowl will be the opposite of the 90's Bills because the AFC is so strong this time around.

Even a fake where you pull back and hit a late releasing tight end. Creativity off your tendencies. Coaching against the best on this stage demands it.

This is the thing with me about McDermott. Attention to detail, especially in the playoffs. Overly relying on the systems. They had the tush push defensed and only once did we try a two count coming out of a time out. Give me a break Coach Obvious! Meanwhile Mahomes is running that sweep right with impunity and down a defender in that area all night. Elam had that stupid face mask penalty but we take our most athletic press DB and have him play way off his receiver all night. At least give him some chances to perform. So many small details Reid accounted for and ours didn't. I don't want McDermott fired but want to hear how he improves his coaching and retools our defense. He needs to more fully realize what it takes to win these games.

Yep, the defense is a weak point but if they fail I feel like they have to adjust their overall defensive strategy and personnel. Not a total teardown, but a significant change in philosophy and personnel. I Definitely want the commanders. They're playing with house money whereas Philly's got the swagger of past experience.

I think it's wise of him. You know he got promoted to OC on the fly last year, focused on that and settled in this year. Next year he can devote some time to learning the ropes of HC from McDermott so he's more prepared to hit the ground as a HC after next season.

After the Ravens game they were interviewing Damar and he specifically mentioned Cole Bishop’s development had really accelerated since Micah came back and started helping him. Just wish the Bills had done it earlier. Hopefully Cole's learned and seen enough to be successful Sunday.

It's such an amazing time to be a Bills fan. We weren't even supposed to win the East. Everything's locked in now, just root like hell for them as they try and overcome any shortcomings and mistakes to win one for us!

Good luck, try to see the forest through the trees. We are blessed with a top notch owner, organization, and one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game. Everything flows downhill from that. Our team has amazing levels of perseverance and camraderie. Our offense can succeed against any defense in the league. They are so easy to love and root for. At this level of football, a little luck will always be needed, as Ravens found out last week. The Ravens are still a great team and will contend next year. So will we if we can't win it all. But enjoy the journey and the titanic matchups. If luck should not favor us these last two games we are and will remain a great team as we reload and try again. To your words, we are playing football at the highest levels and will continue to do so for many years, hopefully culminating in a trophy. How much simply better is that than those decades of lousy, pointless football? You're letting the past rob you the joy of today and justifying your wallowing with the lack of a Superbowl trophy. I hope you can let it go and put your trust in our guys and live the moments. If we fail, we are only in the middle of what will become another legendary time and players for this franchise.

I think Josh is/was treated differently because before last year, in his quest to be Superman, he made a lot of dumb plays alongside the great ones. Forcing the ball into coverage rather than a wide open underneath route, sacrificing his body to pick up yards on a second down run in the middle of a routine game. Critics are going to be harder on Josh making mistakes playing the game the wrong way vs Lamar's mistakes while playing the game the right way. Especially as everyone could see the greatness in Josh. As Josh's changes prove permanent over time the critics are coming around and will continue to.

Almost, but not quite. Schnow perfect 🥰