BillsVet

Sometimes?

People are just realizing McShay doesn't know anything? Maybe when it's realized that most draftniks want to generate clicks that it'll make sense why the RD1 RB narrative gains steam.

Only on TBD do fans believe that taking a RD1 RB will work. Somehow it's a value-added decision that will take the ball out of your franchise QB's hands, diverts resources from the OL and WR, and means your 2nd round pick from last year has fewer touches. Did taking Spiller with Marshawn and Fred on the roster not happen? That's be a straight-up Buddy Nix level duncery-type call.

Timeless.

McD went with Dorsey because, among other things, Josh would not need to learn an entirely new offense and approved the move. But that was a false sense of security for the HC, who ultimately thought this gave him room to improve the defense even more because the offense was now sustained. I've never thought McD has embraced the HC role and seems to abdicate offense over to the OC. I would compare the promotion from coordinator to HC to becoming a general officer in the Army or Marine Corps. You leave behind the branch you were commissioned into, become a "general" officer and thus need to see a greater picture beyond your specific background. McD just comes off as a super-DC with personnel authority who tolerates the offensive side and doesn't want to nor try to understand the other side of the ball. Oddly enough, it's like a reverse Chan Gailey who was de fact OC, but really had little clue what George Edwards or Wannstache were doing on defense.

Andre Reed went into his 2nd season 37 years ago. Appropriate comparisons have left the building.

A mutual decision...but maybe he wanted to go to an organization that invests in the position after Diggs and beyond what was on the field this season.

Josh Allen had the right stuff in between the ears. Yeah, few people have his physical talent, particularly the arm strength (as we saw at the end of the Lions game) but it's the mental part of overcoming adversity and learning from his mistakes. He'd be one of the last people latching onto the TBD narrative about how hard it was this season with all the off-field stuff. I have no doubt McBeane saw this in the scouting process and it's a big reason why they pursued him.

Philly won the SB under a previous HC (Doug Pederson) when this was written. Writing like this reinforces how large market teams' coverage demands success and, when not achieved, don't hold back in their criticism. If Buffalo was a big market, there'd be a lot more of this writing after the '21 and '22 season playoffs ended for the Bills.

OBD largely does retroactive corrective actions and underperforms against their competition at being proactive and anticipating problems. And that's their job, not looking back, fixing what didn't work the previous season and then seeing new problems unfold. WR is a perfect example...where they over-estimated their own talent, made no moves to improve the position beside a late round pick and 1 year UFA contract, and the offense limped into the off-season. And that happened as @BADOLBILZ noted Brown and Beasley declined/aged.

The Bills created a situation where they spent liberally on UFAs, then didn't draft a replacement for those types, and now find themselves with cap issues and few options. WR is a perfect example. When they signed Brown in Beasley to 3 and 4 year deals respectively, they should have simultaneously planned to replace them. But they didn't, and we're back to needing WR help. Or, they'll sign Emanuel Sanders to a 1 year deal and then just assume Davis will step up. Really poor personnel planning. Need to start drafting better...on offense especially. No to a veteran UFA who is looking at a moderate sized contract at 2 or 3 years unless they're going to draft someone high as well who can step in if the veteran falters.

A root cause of Buffalo's 2022 season ending in flames (again) was their inability to run the ball effectively. And the best action to address this is to add a high priced back with 1200 touches in 5 seasons. Sure. Sports media clearly peddling click-bait articles and not doing real in-depth analysis of this team's problems. If they did, they'd see the lack of quality investment in the OL was a prime cause and yet, even minus Josh's carries, Buffalo averaged 4.8 yards per carry last season. (1,470 yards on 306 carries). Because unless Barkley gives them north of 6.0 yards per carry and 9.0 yards per reception , this is not close to value. And even then, on what he'll want in UFA...it's not value.

Every single team is bound by resource limitations...it's how an organization scores their positional priorities that matters. Compare any position group on defense versus the offense and you'll see this. The DB's, LBs, and DL all have received more in picks/UFA dollars compared to the OL, RB/WR/TE position groups. If (and it's only 'if) they believed Davis could graduate to being a WR2 on the basis of that 2021 AFC Divisional Round game, then their decision makers are extremely lacking.

It's not just the catch rate, it's the (lack of) targets. Buffalo had 551 attempts in 2022, 154 of which went to Diggs which is understandable. But on the ~400 other targets, Davis had less than a quarter of those on a team with a decent but not exceptional option at TE and little at the slot WR. I have to believe that after that KC game, McBeane and their All-Star Personnel Team assumed Davis would start catching more passes and getting open more jumping from WR3 to WR2. Or, they wanted to believe in their assessment of Davis because they wanted more defense. People care about firing Frazier, but those doing the self-scouting of their own players at OBD and/or prioritizing positional needs really need to be examined. Especially on offense where they continually fail to invest and, when they do, the results are underwhelming. Too many misses at the skill positions.

Interesting to see how Cincy handles this for a player who performed at a position of value, albeit a WR2. Buffalo avoided this through extensions on all of their 2017-19 draftees who were average or better players and would have come up for a new deal (Tre, Dawkins, Milano, Allen, T. Johnson, Knox). The lone exception until this off-season was Harrison Phillips. Closest comp was when Milano's deal expired, he hit UFA and came back on a sizable contract for the position. Now they're facing the tough decisions most teams have trying to sustain a winning team and that's harder than building a roster from the ground up.

I'm not sure what the problem is Bill, the passing game is how you win...defending it that is. Another safety is possible even if it's not the first round, could definitely see a 2nd pick because McBeane loves to go need with that pick.

The only guarantees in life are death and taxes. Not 1st round MLBs. Sorry.

How many game changing MLB's haven't forced a fumble in their last 77 regular and post-season games on ~4,100 snaps played?

He's had chances to adapt, particularly with Josh's ascendance into a franchise QB and did not. Perhaps he has an epiphany this off-season, but I doubt it. It's surprising how 6 years into the McD regime the offense features misaligned personnel or they avoid investing in certain areas. Or, how they continue doubling down on defense in spite of how the league rules emphasize offensive production.

Certainly. But you can't just blame the Safeties coach and use the injuries as a reason they weren't better defensively. Something's gotta give there. And hey, maybe it's to finally become a more scheme diverse unit and the incoming guy is better suited to that.

It's strange that McD would toss aside an assistant who's been serving in the NFL under the HC for 6 seasons, was in year 1 as safeties coach and had been promoted twice before his latest role. But let's say it's more related to scheme diversity...that still points to this not being a focus for a few years and the HC shares in that. It shouldn't take 5+ seasons to understand that modern offenses going up against specific alignments in coverage are going to figure them out. Seems more like throwing a deck chair off the Titanic after their drubbing versus Cincinnati.

Is that why they're 21M over the cap 4 years after finally clearing, according to their view, the dead cap from the previous regime?

It's a good question...that's been asked for more than a year, but now receives scrutiny because it has not worked in crucial moments. You can spend on on a DL, but there's got to be give somewhere else. For 2023 (and it's early), Buffalo is 8th in defensive spending, but only one of the teams ahead have a major QB contract (GB) and they're not a model of efficiency. The time to assess scheme value and positional priorities was last off-season before Josh's extension hit their books. But they didn't and signed 4 UFA DL (not including Von) within the first week of UFA last March. Ironically, it was the last one of that group, D. Jones, who was their best. What is clear is that overall spending on defense, draft and UFA dollars, is impeding their offense more than many here could see until the Cincinnati game. Each of the final 4 teams had several top-end offensive skill players, but Buffalo did not. Good to see the conversation around DL and defense in general, but it's a day late and a dollar short. Now McBeane have themselves in a hole they created looking up at another AFC team built more solidly in less time than theirs.

All GMs make mistakes, but some make more and then get fired. Others achieve moderate results and eventually get fired. A select few, typically those who draft a true franchise QB, win championships and stay on. Then again, it takes ownership to be invested just enough. The Pegula's have given McBeane everything they've asked for it appears...and at some point they'll tire of excuses and bad playoff results with a 258M investment on the payroll.

I've have not observed enough to indicate OBD A) values offense compared to their major AFC competitors B) identifies and acquires talent in the draft and UFA that C) fits an aligned scheme which can succeed in the modern NFL. This off-season has to be a tremendous departure from previous years when they found a reason not to improve their offense around Josh. It certainly could happen, but it should not have taken this playoff loss to reveal this gap.