His floor is very low. He can lose his mechanics and make very bad reads/decisions. At his worst he looks all over the place. I think, at his worst, he’s weaker as a QB than Mahomes and Burrow at their lowest point. Mind you, want does that mean? That he’s probably better than everyone else, comparatively speaking. Perhaps defenses are just improving all the time which is making QB play more extreme one way or the other (has to be superb at times to break through, and can look awful if it doesn’t work out).
I think he could improve on the basics. Take what’s offered a bit more. Don’t take so much on himself, especially when the run game is working - arguably that’s as much on Dorsey. As I said, at his best he’s the number one QB in the league. At the start of the season, pre bye, I thought we had lost Sugar High Josh for good. Perhaps it will always be part of him.