-
Posts
13,703 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by Beck Water
-
Nyhiem Hines Restructures - Takes a pay cut to stay in Buffalo.
Beck Water replied to Draconator's topic in The Stadium Wall
I don't disagree in principle, but my first reaction when I read that is "how are they at pass protection?" RBs typically improve in pass pro between year 1 and 2, so Cook may step up. I don't recall Hines being very good at it. Of course, if we had a better OL to start with and a QB more willing to take the short pass option, it could be less of a concern. -
Nyhiem Hines Restructures - Takes a pay cut to stay in Buffalo.
Beck Water replied to Draconator's topic in The Stadium Wall
McKenzie ran a pretty full route tree. I'm not saying what the Bills do - it depends on who they bring in, surely - but I don't think you look at Hines and McKenzie as equivalent at all. One thing is, McKenzie is owed a roster bonus of $250,000 this Fri, so if they cut him, they likely cut him this week. My guess is that he comes into camp and competes. -
Nyhiem Hines Restructures - Takes a pay cut to stay in Buffalo.
Beck Water replied to Draconator's topic in The Stadium Wall
Does anyone know exactly how they handled it yet? -
I can see your point Two counter points - 1) I think the top skill position players will be hard for the Bills to afford and frankly, I'm a bit under-enthused at the FA WR crop. Meyers? Tik-Tok Boy? Lazard? Slayton (I think the Giants will re-sign him)? Chark? Parris Campbell really interests me, I'll grant. Who you want? 2) Are the Bills good at evaluating OL talent in the draft? Cody Ford near the top of the 2nd round and Spencer Brown near the bottom of the 3rd have me.....concerned. Boogie Basham 2 picks before Creed Humphrey is another big head-shaker. I think we need a combination of FA, where you can usually see how a guy can play, and draft. Maybe Kromer will make a difference, I don't know. There's also the point that's been made that while pricey, a FA guard may be a better bargain than a FA WR or TE, even FA RB.
-
"one of the Bills top 5 or 6 players this year" #2 offense Allen Diggs Morse Dawkins #2 Defense DaQuan Jones Edmunds Milano Poyer I think you could make an argument for top 10-12 Maybe you meant on defense?
-
JMO but I think the Bills need both, not either/or. Sign the best guy we can get AND draft one. Morse is no spring chicken and could be lost to a concussion at any time. What the Bills did with Eric Wood where we started him a couple years at guard than moved him to C would work for me Thought KC planned to re-sign him. They gave up a lot in that trade to treat him like a rental
-
Matt Milano Contract Extension, as per Adam Schefter
Beck Water replied to SCBills's topic in The Stadium Wall
Did you mean under? Allen alone should put us from over to under -
No argument on those points. My point was with the value of the coach’s recommendation of him as “most NFL ready receiver”. I don’t think that particular coach had a basis to tell
-
I think the Zay Jones issue was that his coach wasn’t an NFL level coach and didn’t know what he didn’t know IIRC he hasn’t been back in the NFL since.
-
Per Shefty - Bills “expected to lose” Poyer and Edmunds
Beck Water replied to BeastMode54's topic in The Stadium Wall
The year he re-signed, there were a lot of stories in the press and posts here that the Bills were expected to be out-bid in the open market. Milano himself trolled fans (and maybe the Bills FO a bit) posting pictures of his dinner with a yacht salesman etc. Then he decided he wanted to stay, and re-signed just prior to FA- by which time I’m sure his agent had a great read on his FA value. He probably took a bit less to stay here but not a lot. Edmunds may feel he can earn Roquan Smith $$ and maybe he can, but I don’t think the Bills can/will pay that -
The fact that it happened with Davante Adams and has happened in the past with a handful of players does not refute the fact that it seldom happens, which is the claim you are addressing with “why do you guys not look up facts before posting?” It could, theoretically, happen with any player who has a strong market but the fact remains it’s risky business for a team with tight cap space (or no cap space) because they only have a week between the tagging and the need to be under the cap on the first day of the league New Year. So trade partners are aware of that, and can push for a “fire sale”, and if the trade doesn’t go through the team is in a bind. Adams was arguably the best WR in the league. Do you think any of the Bills FA, including Edmunds, are arguably the best players at their positions in the league?
-
Daniel Jones wants more than $45M per year on new deal
Beck Water replied to billsbackto81's topic in The Stadium Wall
They’re saying $82M guaranteed in the first 2 years. -
Diggs unfollows Buffalo, follows Cowgirls 🤷♂️
Beck Water replied to DaggersEOD's topic in The Stadium Wall
This here says it’s not true. Purged his twitter feed (does this most years). Still follows Bills, Allen etc on Insta & Twitter -
Diggs unfollows Buffalo, follows Cowgirls 🤷♂️
Beck Water replied to DaggersEOD's topic in The Stadium Wall
Dude look around first Not when it would involve the player giving back bonus they’ve already been paid and converting it to salary to reduce dead cap, which is what would have to happen. Not allowed -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
Press, at the combine -
Leslie Frazier "taking a year off from coaching" per Bills PR
Beck Water replied to Roundybout's topic in The Stadium Wall
Conspiracy theorists may enjoy: https://www.oleantimesherald.com/sports/frazier-s-exit-doesn-t-pass-the-sniff-test/article_bb6b04e1-728e-5aaf-90f5-4c10252813dc.html I mean, he's not wrong about the "sniff test" in the sense that I can't recall another coach, under contract, taking a voluntary year off. "Unprecedented" is the word that comes to mind. I think there's more to it. On the other hand, he's fluffing up the hiring of Al Holcomb as "defensive assistant" as suspicious. We did something similar on the offensive side last year, hiring Mike Shula, and a couple of Bills press guys have pointed out differences in how Holcomb used LBs and Joe Danna used safeties as changes the Bills may wish to employ He's also microanalyzing Beane's response to a reporter's question about whether Frazier would be the DC if he hadn't decided to take a year off. Beane was asked if Frazier would still be the DC if he hadn't decided to take a year off and Beane said "Yes". It really isn't so suspicious when you watch the presser. He's not fluffing up the point that Frazier was himself a championship winning CB, that his youngest son played CB for Rice, and that what happened to Damar may have hit him personally and hard. The Hamlin thing is pretty well unprecedented, as well. -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
C'mon man. Someone being fat does not put the rest of the public at risk of death or serious injury. Driving recklessly - drag racing on public streets in a suburb with other cars on the road - does. Heck even violating traffic laws like failing to stop at a red light or failin It's pretty nonsensical to suggest limiting the kind of cars adults can buy as a solution, but countering it with a personal health issue and suggesting that food be regulated is an absurd analogy. If that's the best ideas and reasoning you got, quit now. -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
I'm not gonna go there with the "wrongful arrest", but it has been known to happen that people call into the police for, lets say, spurious reasons. My FIL, about as law abiding a person as one can find, was once pulled over by two very nervous (hence aggressive) officers for "transporting weapons" after someone called it in, and they weren't made less nervous when my late MIL pulled her car off the road behind them. (The "weapons" observed were metal kitchen chair legs) Apparently the "open alcohol container between his legs" was found to be half full of tobacco spit. I'm sure if it was alcohol, and open, they would have gotten him with "open container" at the least. The "loaded firearm in the car" - c'mon Man, this is Texas. A loaded firearm in the car is only a problem if another felony has been committed. So once the other charges went away, the firearms charge went with them. A late friend of mine used to quip, when he was enroute from Indiana to Texas to take up a job "when I crossed the Texas border, they searched my car for firearms. Fortunately I had some, so they let me in". As far as the "apparently chances were great"... that has not come up publicly, you may have an inside source but if they didn't test for it, it's an assertion without evidence, and respectfully, law enforcement has been known to circulate self-justificatory stories internally. I'm sure you've encountered this. -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
I hope he hired a good lawyer, but I'm surprised a good lawyer and agent would let him speak. -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
Just a guess, but pretty sure if he stayed and they measured his BAC, it woulda been higher than the legal limit -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
Yeah, I'm familiar with that research. Here's the counterpoint - the brain shows remarkable plasticity as an organ. It changes in response to its environment and the demands placed upon it. When people are exposed to different environments and have different expectations and responsibilities, it's not a stretch to think the brain may develop differently. My Grandfather went to school through 8th grade then 2 years of "business college". At age 15, he went to work full time and was expected to play a significant role as a family breadwinner. This was only unusual, in that a lot of kids of that era went to work full time at age 13, right after 8th grade. Then there was Selective Service, which he was too young for in 1917 but registered for in 1942 (18 to 45). Young men were drafted, trained, and somehow expected to exercise a great deal of responsibility, not infrequently leading other young men in combat. It wouldn't surprise me, if the brains of these young men were examined, or the brains of young men and women elsewhere in the world who are expected to exercise adult-size responsibilities in their late teens/early 20s, if they were found to have significantly more mature pre-frontal cortexes capable of accomplishing executive brain functions at a higher level. In one interview Josh Allen was talking about his grandparents and father and uncles, and how, looking at photos of them at high school age, they had the muscles of "grown ass men" because of the hard manual work they did. My contention: young skeletal muscle develop early if needed and used on regular daily basis; young brain develop regularly if judgement and reasoning needed and used on regular daily basis. Meta in the sense I was using it, more comprehensive or transcending. Transitioning from this specific instance to comprehensive consideration about 20 year old kids, who at one time were considered adults and at 18 for some purposes and 21 for others, legally still are. -
Leslie Frazier "taking a year off from coaching" per Bills PR
Beck Water replied to Roundybout's topic in The Stadium Wall
I mean, there are a couple of points. HC hired this season Broncos - retread Sean Payton Cards - Eagles DC Jon Gannon Texans - 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans Colts - Eagles OC Sean Steichen Panthers - retread Frank Reich 2 retreads, 2 young DCs, 1 young OC HC hired last season Saints - Saints DC Dennis Allen, retread of failed Raiders HC Giants - Bills OC Brian Daboll Bears - Colts DC Matt Eberflus Broncos - Green Bay OC Nathaniel Hackett Dolphins - 49ers OC Mike McDaniel LV Raiders -NE OC Josh McDaniels, retread of failed Denver HC and failed Rams OC Vikings - LA Rams OC Kevin O'Connell Jaguars - (out of football) Doug Pederson, retread of Eagles HC who failed to develop Carson Wentz but won a Superbowl and a WC game with Nick Foles Texans - Texans DC Lovie Smith, retread Bucs and Bears HC. With the Bears, Smith managed a Div, Conf, and SB appearance w/ QB Orton, Cutler, and Grossman 4 retreads (counting Allen as a retread), 1 middle-aged DC, 3 young OCs So it's clearly not true that only hot young offensive coaches are being hired. 6 of the HC hires of the last 2 seasons are re-tread HCs, and 5 of 14 were defensive coaches. However, only 2 of the 6 retreads hired were defensive coaches. Leaving aside the "race" question, I think it's fair for Frazier to look at his accomplishments and say that he's shown at least as much as other coaches who got a 2nd chance. What did Josh McDaniel do in Denver? 8-8, 4-12. What did Dennis Allen do with the Raiders? Two 4 and 12 seasons, one of them with Carson Palmer who moved to AZ and promptly showed that he could still play at a high level. As DC, Allen led a couple top defenses (#4 and #5) with NO but they fizzed in the playoffs. Meanwhile, Frazier has had 3 #1 or #2 defenses in his 6 years, and two of the years he didn't were rebuilding. As a HC, he took the Vikes to 10-5 and a playoff appearance with Ponder as his QB. Obviously, he'd get more looks if his D had performed better for the last 13 seconds last season and in the Cincy game this season, but failure of his defense to perform in a playoff game doesn't seem to have been a bar to Dennis Allen. So why is that? I'm not saying "race" is the answer, but I think it would be naive to think that it doesn't factor in. The owners of NFL teams are, for the most part, old white guys, and for the most part, all of us (black white M F) are simply more comfortable with people who remind us of ourselves in some way. Mostly we aren't even consciously aware of this kind of bias. It wouldn't be a surprise to me if that question weighed on Frazier, as another season with a top ranked D and a playoff win apparently failed to get him so much as a phone call, while the Broncos traded away what? to get Payton out of retirement. I would imagine there is an element of frustration there. It's common advice for guys who have not made it as HC to take a year off before taking another position, so that they can be sure they have time to do a thorough "lessons learned". That might apply to Frazier, as well. As an immediate reason to step away and at this time, I'm not sure. I would guess, that either there was going to be a change in the defense that he wasn't comfortable with - Joe Danna I think was brought in from Houston and Al Holcomb, whose longest experience was as LB coach of the Panthers, in part because the Bills want to utilize their safeties and LB a bit differently. Maybe Frazier isn't comfortable with that? It's also possible that McDermott decided that he was going to call defensive plays next season, and Frazier understandably sees that as a demotion. Then there's the possibility that there are medical or family reasons. After listening to Beane's entire presser, I personally think that is less likely. The whole bit about he doesn't want to retire and Beane isn't sure if he'll be coaching with the Bills in 2024 just doesn't sound like a guy who asked for leave for those reasons, but that's entirely a personal opinion. -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
We seem to be infantalizing early-20s kids these days and acting as though that's the norm. If we're gonna go all "meta" here: maybe that should stop. I mean, Durrrr, but is that supposed to be a problem or something? Or does it hit a "soft spot" in you? In other words, What's Your Point? -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
I have sped,and driven recklessly, but not 1) in a populated area 2) while under the influence of alcohol. It's one thing to die or risk turning into a vegetable for your own kicks, and another to risk inflicting that on someone else. No DUI, car he was driving was not in an accident What's Your Point? -
Potential Number 1 pick Jalen Carter Arrest Warrant
Beck Water replied to CountDorkula's topic in The Stadium Wall
I doubt that there are sidewalks in that particular area, but otherwise, Thank You. This. This was not a long empty straight deserted country road. There were other cars on the road, a road busy enough to have a center turn lane, and they were passing them. Then I don't even know what to say to you. Yes I do - you were an ####### when you did it, you were putting innocent bystanders at almost as much risk as if you were twirling around shooting a gun, and you really need to quit normalizing this as something just "everybody does". https://fox2now.com/news/missouri/teen-volleyball-player-from-tennessee-critically-injured-in-downtown-st-louis-crash/ This kind of thing. There's a young lady - a young lady who entered the weekend with a full ride volleyball scholarship to college - who just lost both her legs and whose life will never be the same (if she lives) because #######s think that traffic laws don't apply to them. The driver and the other car are fine, of course -the car and its engineering protected them, but not the young lady who was walking down the sidewalk minding her own business. You did it, you don't do it now, Good for You, but don't normalize it.