Billl

It’s inexcusable that the 170th pick in the draft isn’t ready to start in game 7 of his rookie season? In all probability, his upside is career backup based solely on his draft slot.

Cornelius Johnson, Marcus Rosemy-Jacksaint, Tahj Washington, Xavier Weaver, Javon Baker, Ainias Smith, Johnny Wilson, Jordan Whittington, and Tayvion Robinson are all complete and total busts to this point. A few of them have literally never taken a snap in the NFL. Tahj Washington is on the chart right between Malik Nabers and Brian Thomas Jr. despite having played 3 career snaps without registering a stat. This chart is a complete fabrication.

It’s 100% meaningless. There is literally zero value in this chart. You want proof? Take a look at Cornelius Johnson on the center left. He’s never played a snap in the NFL. Tahj Washington is next to Malik Nabors. Tahj has played 3 career snaps and has never recorded a stat. This chart has no value whatsoever.

McConkey is a stud, but this chart is meaningless. Roman Wilson is a complete bust to this point, and he charts as elite.

Yeah, that’s just a terrible play. The only tiny bit of hope Minnesota has is if LA turns it over. And somehow, seemingly by accident, the Vikings just managed to score.

WTF?

What in God’s name was that play call?

You failed to factor in the part where Beane also traded away the only true #1 WR Josh has ever had during that period.

Egbuka is a stud.

Some of this is fine (throwing more to the RBs), but most of it is just paper-shuffling. He’s saying to feature Larry Ogunjobi, Michael Hoecht, Shaq Thompson, Joshua Palmer, Jordan Poyer, and Dawson Knox. Is that list of names really going to change anything? The other two suggestions are to play your first round CB and Dalton Kincaid when they get healthy and to add more talent (not exactly novel ideas). I feel like this list is more of an indictment of Beane than it is useful suggestions for McDermott.

Isn't that a first down for Houston and a touchback (penalty notwithstanding)?

I think you’ve got that backwards. When Brady took over, Josh’s rushing attempts went through the roof. He averaged 9 carries a game after the switch whereas he never had 9 carries in a game that season when Dorsey was calling the plays.

Imagine not giving credit to Brady for winning his 7th Super Bowl in dominant fashion because he didn’t rack up a ton of passing yards.

How could this not have been thrown normally?

Seems like Rashee Rice should be added to that list.