Rich, backhanded compliment here, but you are one of a few opinions I really trust. But no Mcnally is not, and I am not sure ever reason was, the lord of lords. I think that was hype.
But Baltimore Oline replaced Anderson with Mulitalo and had Ogden looking bad as a result this year. Ogden I think was in fact helped in the past by an above average Anderson, who while maybe got stupid motion penalties in B'more, didn't really get beat. This year Anderson looked to have technique problems, and i blame the coach. He started getting better towards the end of the year, and other then his weight and inability to pull effectively, he was probably the best Olineman at the end of the season.