i agree with your point. If they both have the same amount of “bad” plays in a game Edmunds will get criticized.
I’m saying the reason Milanos mistakes are not pointed out as much is because he regularly makes splash plays that offset the bad ones. He has many more ints, forced and recovered fumbles and tackles for loss. So right or wrong that’s why he isnt criticized as much.
now what? Criticize Milano more or gloss over Edmunds’ weaknesses?