Maye is probably ahead of where Josh was at this point of his career, but Josh came in about as raw as can be. He is a good QB but he is no Josh Allen. I think Maye has a chance to be elite but saying he is now is way premature.
I maintain my position that the Bills biggest problem on defense is missed tackles. I remember McDs first few years and the reason bend but don't break worked so well was the guys swarmed the ball fast and made the tackle.