Ive seen a few people reference the 2014 defensive roster in defense of Whaley, in this thread and the Gillislee thread, but i want to remind everyone that Whaley did not build that roster. Nix did. Whaley has been quite average. Not the worst, but not the best.
As far as a comparison to Polian and his record, Polian was a complete animal when he was here, he took control of everything. It was Polians team through and through, even fighting over it with an immensely strong willed and meddling owner in Ralph. Polian took control.
Whaley is a flippity floppity flue of a GM that by most accounts, hasnt even had the nut sack to hire his own coach yet. Yes, Whaley is a professional football talent evaluator, he can see and pick some individual talent and has hit on a couple players. I just dont think he is savvy enough, at this point, to build a complete football team. Im not a fan of Whaley as the GM of our beloved Buffalo Bills.