What went wrong is the Bills took the field.
Actually, things started ok. McCoy had a couple runs and Peterman completed a couple passes to our guys.
Then things went downhill fast and it was Peterman's fault. If he hadn't thrown that ball to Benjamin, he wouldn't have injured his knee. Tyrod wouldn't have attempted that throw and Benjamin lives to play decoy in more games this year.
The following play I believe, Dimarco had an easy one bounce off his hands, would've hit him in the face if it didn't hit his hands, and was returned for a TD. Game over.