How is Williams justified? Just because he was not considered a project? He now is struggling to maintain a roster spot on the Redskins, and was drafted #4 overall. IMO, drafting a guy in the Top 5 that stayed on the roster for 4 years is worse than a project player that came out at the age of 20.
Now I'm not saying Maybin was a good pick, just that I believe Williams was a worse one. We do have the advantage of knowing how bad Williams sucks, while the jury is still out on Maybin. The simple fact that Williams was #4 overall and Maybin was #11 makes it a worse pick.