If a QB goes 0/0 0 yards and 0 TD's and wins, he did what he had 2.
If a QB goes 22/37 306 2 TD's and 1 pick and loses, is that a good game?
Those are Pennington's numbers btw, from the loss to the Patriots.
What you don't seem to get is that you MUST evaluate individual players within the context of the team, and the individual game they are playing in.
Example:
Cadillac Williams ran 15 times for 37 yards against the Falcons.
Had 7 carries in the first 2 drives.
Is he a bust? No, his team was playing behind the entire game so he was a non factor.
Vick on the other hand was 10/15 91 1td 1pick
No need for the big game throwing when they ran for 300 yards on the ground. While running down the clock up 14-0.
I'm not saying that JP is even close to being there yet, but you have to take his game in context and in that case he played extremely well. (For what he was asked to do)