Joe Marino is no Josh hater but he calls things as he sees them. And I think his takes are better than most because he at least gives a reason for his takes, unlike most drunk callers to the 'GR postgame.
The thing with Josh seems to be a combination of things: 1) McDermott limiting his natural instincts 2) having played a Giants team that knew Josh's tendencies and 3) giving that plan to Bill Belichick.
Again, Josh had some bad throws. But his teammates all shared the goat horns this week. Drops, penalties, wrong patterns, then the defense getting led by the nose by Noodle-arm MacCorkle. Do you realize the Pats ran the exact same play at the goal line to win the game? They saw they beat Taron Johnson on that throw the first time. Only a bad pass prevented a TD. So they ran that play again with Gesicki. How do you let that happen?