MrEpsYtown

Maybe like you have to clap and if you stop clapping you die or something

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DRUgIFvDjbw/?igsh=anJ6dzhyY3c0OGFw

Cleaning house aside from trying to keep Kromer. My head coach hire is Kliff Kingsbury. He obviously knows offense and knows how to move the football. He’s the most obvious guy to have more success in his second go around. I don’t see him as a retread, I see him as a guy who had some success and some failure and will do better in a better situation. Someone will hire him this year and his success will on some level depend on his QB is. He’s done some really good things with Jayden Daniels. He took the Cards to the playoffs with Kyler Murray missing multiple games, and receivers like a washed AJ Green and Greg Dortch and TBD favorite Andy Isabella behind DeAndre Hopkins who got hurt and was a big part of their late season collapse. He also has found very creative ways to utilize Zach Ertz, something he could do with Kincaid. He needs to be paired with an experienced DC like Jim Schwartz. Maybe it’s a Flores or something, but I would target Schwartz. Thats the move I make. Kliff maybe isn’t as kind and God fearing as McDermott, but to me he’s the kind of offensive coach who needs another shot and is a perfect pairing with Josh. He is able to maximize skill sets, and he has shown an implementation of more gap runs in Washington which shows that he has likely learned from some of his mistakes in Arizona and his vanilla zone scheme. Often these guys find success in a second go round and to me he’s the guy to target.

And that's why we gotta stop the bleeding here and now. More years of this is just not good.

IMO, you cannot be scared to move on, worried about who will replace him. That's playing scared. That's McDermott's philosophy, and now it makes sense why people in that headspace want to keep him. People are afraid to lose. McDermott is afraid to lose. You can't live that way. Get busy living or get busy dying...this thing has been fading away for years now. And that seems to be the sentiment. We all pretty much know he sucks, and deep down know he won't win the big game. And the fanbase seems to be split into a group that knows he sucks but is afraid to move on and a group that wants a different voice. Then have your few loyalists who give him cart blanche because he ended the drought. He isn't it, and it will never happen with him. It does not matter who you hire because in this situation, different is better. He's a terrible head coach. Does anyone really, truly, deep down believe that we can win a Super Bowl with this guy at the helm?

100% has outstayed his welcome, and his expiration date is long overdue. Everyone can see what is happening here. Getting us into the playoffs doesn't give one a lifetime achievement award. Beane needs to go with him. Total overhaul.

Perhaps. At least the wild card path puts the chip back on their shoulder some. Maybe they become road warriors. Josh is typically at his best when everyone thinks he blows and he feels like he has to prove the haters wrong.

I mean yeah I agree. And my psychoanalysis of Josh, and again these are just my thoughts that many will disagree with, and that’s fine being a public forum…but he’s gonna stay humble and be a good teammate and a good soldier because he’s the guy who was never supposed to be here and he somehow is. And I’m sure in some weird way that is always going to be in the back of his mind. Sometimes we see things spiral and unravel when he makes mistakes and that’s a confidence thing. The only hope for change is that he turns on these guys, and it just isn’t going happen. Josh sometimes feels like he’s happy to be here. Brady was a killer, he was more like F you, I’m the man…you thought I wasn’t, you doubted me, now I’m going to aggressively make you pay for years for doubting me. And his coach was a POS who was out to embarass people week to week by any means necessary. Our guy is a nice guy who claps and our QB is a nice guy who is happy to be here. And while that can have good vibes, it typically doesn’t win. Iron sharpens iron, championship teams push each other to the brink. True leadership sometimes forces you to be the bad guy and that’s where Josh has to get to for this to work. He needs to be a dick, like Brady, like Rodgers, like Mahomes. He kinda needs to call out his teammates and coaches, but instead he blames himself every week. Either that or we need a coach who is a dick who will get the best out of his players. This nice-nice stuff just doesn’t win the majority of the time. Somebody needs to do something to shake things up.

100% this

Team unprepared, sloppy and uninspired falls at the feet of the HC. Bottom line.

Yeah you defintely make good points. The fact that they never tried to build this into an offensive machine is a great tragedy of wasted opportunity. When you have Josh, you should not be ball control. It’s just a failure of epic proportions and I place it at the feet of McDermott and Beane. I don’t understand blaming Josh or Brady. This is what this brain trust built and this is what they wanted, and it’s dumb.

And that’s why they need to change course. Josh will be fine and has the potential for a really good second half of his career. But he’s in a transition period and he’s becoming a different player. What worked before ain’t working anymore. The team needs a reset and it starts at the top. The “we can all be mediocre cuz Josh will bail us out” concept is no more. McDermott is the definition of mediocre. And that’s fine. He will land on his feet and build the Giants into a playoff contender who can’t win the big game and waste Dart’s career. But we have to move on.

yeah it doesn’t matter. This thing is past its best by date. I hate to say it but part me is ok with missing the playoffs if it means they blow this thing up. Keep the QB and change everything else. Sometimes you have to take two steps back to move forward. Give ground to gain ground.

Its insane. It’s driving 30 miles an hour in a Bugatti. I don’t get it.

This is what McDermott wants. He wants conservative, old school, football because he is a wuss. He is milquetoast. He is Dick Jauron. It’s a bend but dont break defense. It’s ball control offense. Its dumb. Brady’s offense was not like this in other stops. It’s McDermott.