It's not overreaction when you see a quarterback, no matter how experienced, unable to accurately throw three yard passes, make no attempt to look off receivers, throw into quadruple coverage, which he once did, almost never use his supposed "great" arm (except perhaps on the pass that was picked off), and in no way show the presence of a leader. Look at tapes of Peyton Manning his first year and you'll see what I mean. Yes, perhaps PM's an exception but it's not clear EJ should have been a high first round pick in any case.