Nuts? Yeah, ok.
Aaron Rodgers is one of the very best QBs this game has ever seen. He makes the people around him better.
I remember some Peyton Manning offenses looking very healthy in Indy, then boom! They're 2-14 without him.
And if your claims were true then the Packers would have accepted a haul for Aaron and rode with Jordan Love, you know, since the team around him would be so great.