Wow. Prep/Jock/Cheerleader with Loner a close second. I wore a t-shirt and jeans almost every day, didn't play any sports, and doubt many in my class of 400 even knew my name. Go figure.
I'd say loner is more accurate. I think that the fact that I love sports, wanted to be popular, and had a tight clique (of a few fellow loners) probably pushed me towards my result.