HerdMenatlity1

Gonna be nice to have him back.

Wrong

So, some of you want to replace Star with someone who contemplated retirement and now says he'll "try" to play one more year, after an injury plagued year. ?. This Star hatred is ridiculous. Like it or not, saw it or not, he anchored our dline last year. Stop it already. https://www.freep.com/story/sports/nfl/lions/2020/02/20/detroit-lions-release-dt-damon-harrison-retirement/4826150002/

I voted Oliver, but hope it's Ford.

1st attempt at a poll. 2018: I looked at the list of drafted players and it made sense to only include these 2 players. Harrison would have definitely made the list if not for his injury. My vote is Allen over Edmunds. After a start to the season where Allen seemed to be a turnover machine, he turned it around. He cut down on turnovers and was playing as well as any qb not named Patrick Mahomes or Lamar Jackson. Edmunds improved, just not at the rate of improvement shown by Josh. Hopeful that Harrison will show the same improvement. 2019 There seems to be quite a few more players with potential to show dramatic improvement over the 2018 draft. I can see where our first 4 picks last year improve dramatically. My vote is Oliver. He played NT in college and was double teamed a lot. He then switched to 3-tech DT where he could take on more single man opportunities. I think he comes back stronger and with a better idea of what works for him in his new position. From there, it's a toss up on who will improve the most. Pretty sure I read somewhere that Knox will work out with Josh in the off-season. If he does, he has the potential to make a big jump from his rookie season.

Sean Lee can get hurt stepping on a rubber mat. Nigel over Sean any day.

We drafted Sweeney.

We're kinda thin at LB. Pretty sure we're drafting a LB, but I wouldn't mind signing Nigel too. The contract would have to make sense and seeing how Beane operates, I'm sure it will. Kick the tires Get er done If the price is right Side note: I met his mom and family and watched a Philly game with them. She said Nigel loved his time in Buffalo. Even as Florida baby, he loved the city and had nothing but good things to say about Buffalo and how the fans treated him. He's a hockey fan now too.

Hell Yeah!!!

Happy he didn't sign here. I think Knox and Kroft will work out fine. I think they'll combine to get 80 receptions and 12 tds. We need to concentrate on finding a wr, rb, lb and de more than te. Man, I need a pair of those Josh Allen colored sunglasses you have. ?

You couldn't put his name in the title? Click bait?

Good question. I don't have an answer. I won't be pissed if they franchise him, but would prefer something else for that amount of $. Unless we feel we are SB ready.

I do agree with building the trenches. He's not a star to me, though. If I thought he was, I would be for it. Even splitting time.

I get that, but he's going to split time with Oliver. That's a lot of $ for a part time player, even for 1 yr. We can make this a better/deeper team with that $15M.

Not making much sense for a player that will split time with Oliver. I'd rather use that $ somewhere else. $8-10 on a WR or LB maybe?

It's the quiet ones you have to watch out for.

Not buying it.

My eyes are hurting now.?

Fanspeak RD1 #22 CB Bryce Hall, Virginia RD2 #54 LB Zack Baun, Wisconsin RD3 #86 RB Cam Aikers, FSU RD4 #123 WR Jauan Jennings, Tennessee RD5 #155 WR Collin Johnson, Texas RD5 #167 S Shyheim Carter, Alabama RD6 #188 OT Saahdiq Charles, LSU RD6 #201 RB A.J. Dillon, Boston College RD6 # 207 OT Scott Frantz, Kansas State

You're giving your opinion and so is thurman. You not agreeing doesn't equate to him giving excuses. You think there is a huge gap from Star to the " best" out there doing what he does. Cool. Remember, it just your opinion. The excuses line is crap. He has an opinion that opposes yours. It's ok. I don't know it all, thurman doesn't know it all and neither do you. Self righteous attitudes here suck. Get over yourself.

I'm so glad the Daboll haters have to "suffer" at least 1 more year. But can some of you get more creative than "Dumboll"? You come off as dumb as you try to make him to look.

His too.

Including Star.

The only stable player on the defensive interior. Harry gets hurt, Oliver was a rookie, Peko?!, Leuiget?!? and he allowed Jordan to not get doubled. He had an aging de who is in decline next to him(Hughes) and another de who just isn't good(murph). Some guys just don't know how good he was last year. HOPEFULLY Harry comes back healthy, but this defense needed and still needs Star.

You should give it a shot. It can be fun in your down time.