I really liked him in Philly and thought he was a difference maker who won games a mediocre Eagles team should have lost. The nagging question for me is why did he fail so badly once he left Philly? He was terrible in Washington and Minnesota. If had succeeded on more than one team I'd consider him.
I am not a fan of Aikman in the HOF either. Kerry Collins could have won 3 SBs on those Cowboy teams