hondo in seattle

Shaw, you're probably right. Reid probably did become incrementally better with experience. But I stand by my point. I think commentators are too quick to judge that a coach or player can't win the big one just because they haven't yet. An average team has a 3% chance of winning the Super Bowl. A very talented coach or player might elevate the chances to 10% or so. That's it. No matter how talented a coach or player might be, they might not reach the SB. Too many other variables are at play. I thought the Eagles were crazy when they sent Reid packing. No rings - at the time - but the skill was undeniable. I don't think Allen's lack of trophies means anything other than all the necessary conditions haven't fallen in place yet.

Not complicated. Just saying that the narrative that a coach or player can't win the big game just because they haven't yet is wrong-minded. All the conditions have to be right. For coaches, QB is one of the conditions.

I was at Camp Casey in Tong-du-chon (aka Dongducheon), about an hour north of Seoul. I visited Yongsan a few times. It was where the 8th Army was headquartered. In 1988, before credit cards were commonly accepted in Korea, you had to carry cash. One time - long story - I found myself broke in Seoul on a Sunday evening with no way to get back to Camp Casey. So I went to Yongsan, where there was a cashier's booth where I could maybe cash a check, hoping and praying it would be open late on a Sunday. From what I understand, the U.S. garrison that was once there is now gone. I loved serving in Korea and still love Korean food. That was one of the best years of my life. What was it like to live there as a kid?

I think you have to standardize it so you can perfect it. Do thousands of reps at 7 yards: snap, hold, kick... snap, hold, kick...

Andy Reid coached for twenty years before reaching the Super Bowl. The book on him during that stretch was that he was a good regular-season coach but didn't have what it takes to succeed in the playoffs. Now he practically owns the Lombardi. Reid didn't suddenly become a better coach. He's the same coach he was when he supposedly wasn't good enough in the playoffs. Making a playoff off run culminating in a Super Bowl win is hard and the stars need to align: good coaching staff, good roster, good health heading into the playoffs, maybe some luck with calls and bounces... Allen will be the guy who can't win big games until he does. It's not his fault and it's not factual. It's just how sports commentary works.

In the army I hated calling cadence, the call-and-response songs we sing to keep soldiers in step when marching or running. So once when I was stationed in Korea, I learned some Korean cadences from the Korean soldiers serving with us. Korean cadences sound odd and unrhythmic to an American audience. And that's what I sang when the commanding officer called on me to sing cadence. He never called on me again.

If we're going to do anything revolutionary on special teams, let's get rid of our punter, bet on our offense, and never punt the ball. Our scoring would go up. So would our opponent's scoring - we'd just have to outpace them. We could use the extra roster spot on DL - McD loves to rotate there and keep guys fresh.

It's not like we went on a big spending spree. We lost some players Beane probably wanted to retain and signed mostly marginal starters and depth players. The challenges of managing the cap are real. Of course, Beane doesn't publicly telegraph his offseason strategy. But he never said we wouldn't make any moves. He just acknowledged there were limitations to what we could do. Signing a big-name WR, RB, DE, or CB wasn't in the budget.

As a war veteran myself, I have a huge soft spot for those who served, especially those who served and paid the price. I think about Kelso every Memorial Day. He could have gotten a deferment and didn't. Wanted to serve and truly cared about his men. I'm proud he was a Bill. I'm so happy to see he's got a statue. Kalsu is exactly the kind of person that ought to be honored with a statue. I never liked seeing statues dedicated to Confederate, slave-holding traitors. And I'm not happy with some of the people we lionize and valorize these days. As a country, we need the right heroes - selfless, caring, honor and duty-bound guys like Bob Kalsu. Btw, I love BBFL's idea about a special section at Canton for players who served.

Most expensive sports stadiums in the world... 1. SoFi, $5.5 billion 2. Allegiant, $1.9 billion 3. MetLife, $1.7 billion Tied for #4 at $1.5 billion are Wembley, Mercedes Benz, AT&T, and Yankee stadiums. And, of course, the new Bills stadium when complete. Even when you adjust for inflation, the Bills stadium will be in the top twelve or so. I think it's pretty cool that the Bills will have such a nice home in a city that doesn't even rank in the top 100 in the world in population or GDP.

When you have a great QB, you ought to supply him with dynamic weapons (i.e. receivers) and mauling bodyguards (i.e. OL). I'm happy with either.

The average NFL career is 3.3 years. An average NFL player, during his short tenure in the league, will play for 2.4 teams. Roughly 1 in 7 players will sign with Carolina at some point. There are 32 teams each with a 53-man roster. 1,696 players start the season on a 53-man roster. But those rosters change and evolve over the course of the long season. Let's estimate that 2,100 different players are on NFL rosters at some point during a season. Roughly 300 will have Carolina somewhere on their resumes. When Beane goes shopping, there are a lot of ex-Panthers to choose from. Additionally, a vet with more than 3 years of NFL experience will rotate typically rotate through more than 2.4 teams. Williams, for example, has been on 6 professional football rosters including a short stint with the Stampeders. Our old friend, Fitz, played on 9 different teams before hanging up the cleats. The chances of an experienced vet having been at Carolina at some point are fairly good.

That's her uncle. Big fitness guy.

It's bad for players. And it's bad for my family. On Xmas, I'm totally devoted to the wife and kids and whoever else shows up. But if the Bills play, my attention will be divided.

I'm a traditionalist. I don't like rule changes. Except when they promote player safety like this one (hopefully) does.

Sure. But when you tackle, do you think, "This is a hip drop" as opposed to "This is a swivel hip drop"? I understand the risk of injury and the need for a rule. But I also think most defenders are just trying to get the guy down, not trying to hurt anybody. And the NFL rulebook keeps getting longer and more complicated.

Shaw66 is a knowledgeable and respected poster. Calling him Mrs. McDermott isn't respectful. I think as brethren fans who have suffered through a 17-year drought and other trials together, I think we can do better.

When Beane talked about Hyde and didn't rule out re-signing him, my conclusion was that he still wants another safety.

While I think the roster right now is worse than last year's, I'm not a complete curmudgeon. If we enter the playoffs healthy, I believe we have a chance to make a run even with this squad. The best team doesn't always win the Lombardi. Sometimes being healthy and hot make the day - though that's not anything I've ever personally experienced.

Obviously, it depends on need, players available, and so on... But I generally like trading back. Talent evaluation is an imperfect science. There's no certainty in the draft. It's a crap shoot. So the more rolls of the dice, the better your chances of getting someone good.

Doc, I know McGovern is the starter. He was already on the squad last season, so I don't know how Morse's departure makes us better as the OP asserted when the OL roster clearly got worse (Morse released, Clapp signed). Maybe McGovern will be a revelation as a starting center and play better than Morse. And maybe Edwards, who seems likely to take over McGovern's vacated guard spot, plays guard better than McGovern. But it's too many maybes. And for DE... Floyd gave us double digit sacks last season. If you want to think about it this way, his replacement as stud DE is Von who's coming off a significant injury and hasn't had double-digit sack production since 2018. Overall, I'm just not seeing a better roster - yet. Though I'm hoping for the following: * Our key defensive players are healthier this season than they've been the past couple of years. * Beane finds some impact players in free agency and the draft. * Brady turns out to be a lights-out OC who gets the most out of his offensive players.

That's the right question. Offense. WR - maybe a slight step forward. OL - I'm not sure how shedding Morse and picking up the Clapp makes the OL better. OC - I don't know if Brady will be better this year than last year. I hope so. But saying so is just hope and speculation. Overall, the O seems about the same. Defense. We lost some good starters and gained some low-end starters and back-ups. The secondary, in particular, doesn't look as stout as it did back when Poyer, Hyde, and Tre were all in their primes. I'm not seeing a better roster. But health is a factor here. If Milano and the D stays healthier this season than it has in past years, and if Von returns to form, we could perform better defensively than last year. The offseason isn't over yet but - other than Mafia Optimism - I see no reason to believe the roster is better than another top eight finish.

I really hope I'm wrong, but I think when he's done, Beane will make the 2024 roster about as good as 2023's. And that's fine - if the goal is to reach the playoffs.

I disagree that DE is not being talked about. People mention it in "What starting spots still need to be filled?" and other threads. I do agree it's a concern though I guess it depends on how you feel about Von. If he returns to form, we're okay. If not, it's a problem. In today's NFL, you need to pressure the QB and I don't trust Epenesa and Groot to do enough of that. And this isn't our only concern. I'm worried about this being another playoff year that doesn't end in a Super Bowl appearance. Good but not good enough.

The goal of a business is to maximize revenue while minimizing costs. If I owned the Bills and wanted a new stadium, I'd absolutely threaten to follow the Braves to San Diego even though I had no real intention of going anywhere.