What team "won" on trade deadline day-2025 edition

[BuffaloRebound]

Jets and its not even close.  

[Slack_in_MA]

Tell you in two years .

[Donuts and Doritos]

5 minutes ago, BuffaloRebound said:

Jets and its not even close.  

Except they will want to use some of those draft picks to get a QB & early returns are this is a bad QB draft class so the jury's still out. Especially given the Jets QB draft history. But if they hit, then I 100% agree with you.

[Generic_Bills_Fan]

17 minutes ago, ngbills said:

So would TB, PHI, SF, DET and more

Jets also still have Wilson and Hall. Get them a qb and make good draft picks they could be solid pretty quickly. 

I feel like Philly really didn’t trade for anyone midseason either year they won the superbowl unless I’m missing something? which is very possible lol 

I think that’s why op brought up the rams not to put words in anyone’s mouth 😂.

 

The only big swing midseason rental ‘trade’ I can think of that had a big impact was that rams team and that partly required a talented wr basically forcing his way out of his current contract which you can’t always count on. Von was a standard trade though

 

theres a bunch of these half season rental trades every year and they mostly amount to not much of anything.  I’ll never forget everyone panicking the chiefs got uche last year and I don’t think he was even active for the playoffs haha heck the ravens traded for diontae Johnson and had to waive him cuz he was a nutjob 

 

doesn’t mean we shoulda done nothing but I think people are expecting guys like shaheed to do exactly what he’s been doing the second he gets plopped onto the Seahawks but it often doesn’t work out that way 

Edited 5 hours ago by Generic_Bills_Fan

[TBBills Fan]

5 minutes ago, Slack_in_MA said:

Tell you in two years .

Nooooo I need instant reaction please. 

 

I am going be sentenced by then most likely 

3 minutes ago, Donuts and Doritos said:

Except they will want to use some of those draft picks to get a QB & early returns are this is a bad QB draft class so the jury's still out. Especially given the Jets QB draft history. But if they hit, then I 100% agree with you.

Yeah but they seem to be loading for 2027

 

They already have 3 1sts in 2027, plus with the ammo this year, they can add even more for 2027. It would be quite easy to move some of that 2026 for 2027 ammo if they feel that way. Then get a QB plus a good amount pieces in place, both young and through FA

 

4 minutes ago, Generic_Bills_Fan said:

I feel like Philly really didn’t trade for anyone midseason either year they won the superbowl unless I’m missing something? which is very possible lol 

I think that’s why op brought up the rams not to put words in anyone’s mouth 😂.

 

The only big swing midseason rental ‘trade’ I can think of that had a big impact was that rams team and that partly required a talented wr basically forcing his way out of his current contract which you can’t always count on. Von was a standard trade though

 

theres a bunch of these half season rental trades every year and they mostly amount to not much of anything.  I’ll never forget everyone panicking the chiefs got uche last year and I don’t think he was even active for the playoffs haha heck the ravens traded for diontae Johnson and had to waive him cuz he was a nutjob 

I didn't bring up the rams, someone else did!  Rams are ineligible for being declared the "winner" I don't think they made any moves this year

[BuffaloBillyG]

7 minutes ago, BuffaloRebound said:

Jets and its not even close.  

It's not a slam dunk. 

 

They created 2 holes. Can they aquire players equal to or better than the 2 they traded away? Will they land a franchise QB? Maybe they put a huge package of picks together to move to 1st pick (if they don't get it on their own) and take Mendoza? The Colts pick looks like it will be late first round this year. Around where we normally pick. They may have a lot of good picks but they also have a lot of holes. 

 

They really should have went "all in" on the reset and moved Breece Hall and Garrett Wilson if they were going this mode. 

[Generic_Bills_Fan]

3 minutes ago, TBBills Fan said:

Nooooo I need instant reaction please. 

 

I am going be sentenced by then most likely 

Yeah but they seem to be loading for 2027

 

They already have 3 1sts in 2027, plus with the ammo this year, they can add even more for 2027. It would be quite easy to move some of that 2026 for 2027 ammo if they feel that way. Then get a QB plus a good amount pieces in place, both young and through FA

 

I didn't bring up the rams, someone else did!  Rams are ineligible for being declared the "winner" I don't think they made any moves this year

Yea I think the person you were replying to was saying ‘ask the rams who won the Super Bowl with a big midseason trade a couple years ago’ haha unless I replied to the complete wrong thing which is possible my brain doesn’t work as good as it used to 😂

[Goin Breakdown]

46 minutes ago, BuffaloBillsGospel2014 said:

 

The Rams would disagree with you.

Yeah that's true. Hardly not never. 

[BuffaloRebound]

36 minutes ago, BuffaloBillyG said:

It's not a slam dunk. 

 

They created 2 holes. Can they aquire players equal to or better than the 2 they traded away? Will they land a franchise QB? Maybe they put a huge package of picks together to move to 1st pick (if they don't get it on their own) and take Mendoza? The Colts pick looks like it will be late first round this year. Around where we normally pick. They may have a lot of good picks but they also have a lot of holes. 

 

They really should have went "all in" on the reset and moved Breece Hall and Garrett Wilson if they were going this mode. 

Hall and Wilson are young enough to be around awhile to help a QB develop.  You build with offense.  Finding 2 completely desperate organizations to give you 3 first round picks, a 2nd round pick plus 2 young players who were picked in the top 50 of the draft is complete robbery.  I know it’s the Jets but hat tip to them.  

[BuffaloBillyG]

1 minute ago, BuffaloRebound said:

Hall and Wilson are young enough to be around awhile to help a QB develop.  You build with offense.  Finding 2 completely desperate organizations to give you 3 first round picks, a 2nd round pick plus 2 young players who were picked in the top 50 of the draft is complete robbery.  I know it’s the Jets but hat tip to them.  

Agree, they really made out well and got a nice haul. Wilson I can agree, but with how short RB shelf lives are and the fact that he's not signed beyond this year...moving Hall should have been a no brainer for them. 

[US Egg]

2 hours ago, Willie West said:

Arch Manning will be a Jet.

Deja vu?  He goes the route of Uncle Eli and Jets add more 1st’s?

[philholbroo]

Bills win, did not trade future picks in a Superbowl winning season, so all good.