Josh's pass to Palmer that (more or less) won the game

[Generic_Bills_Fan]

5 hours ago, twoandfourteen said:

 

Ok. Let’s do this. Where would any one of Coleman/Shakir/Palmer (CSP) rank on other AFC rosters:

 

MIA — Hill/Waddle. CSP - #3

NYJ — Wilson. CSP - #2

NE — Diggs/Hollins. CSP - #1

 

CIN — Chase/Higgins. CSP - #3

PIT — Metcalf. CSP - #2

BAL — Flowers/Hopkins. CSP - #2/#3

CLE — Jeudy/Tillman. CSP - (even)

 

KC — Rice/Worthy. CSP - #2/#3

LA — McConkey/Johnston.  CSP - #2/#3

LV — Myers/Tucker. CSP - #1/#2

DEN — Sutton/Franklin/Mims. CSP - #2/#3

 

JAX — Thomas/Hunter/Brown. CSP - #2/#3

IND — Pittman/Downs/Mitchell. CSP - #3/#4

HOU — Collins/Kirk/Dell. CSP - #3/#4

TEN — Ridley. CSP - #2

 

Maybe I’ll get around to the NFC later on, but just in the AFC alone — Beane’s WR room easily ranks in the bottom 1/3rd. The only team the Bills are clearly ahead of is the Patriots, which ironically is starting two former Bills “star” WRs. 

 

 

 

I’m not sure about the methodology you’ve chosen here. Why are you treating all 3 of them as one single entity basically? For example with the jets, Garrett Wilson is objectively better than all 3, but every one of Coleman/shakir/palmer is better than every other jets wr…that would be advantage bills to most reasonable people and that logic applies to many other teams here 

 

were you trying to just compare who has the best wr1?  That’s really all you’re doing by looking it like that

 

Edited September 10 by Generic_Bills_Fan

[SageAgainstTheMachine]

5 hours ago, Low Positive said:

We should make a list. It's probably deserves it's own thread. But to start

 

• Robert Foster against the Jags in 2018
• Jake Kumerow in Denver in 2020
• Diggs in Detroit in 2023
• Palmer

The throw to Beasley from his own EZ in the 2019 Thanksgiving game vs the Cowboys.

[hondo in seattle]

2 hours ago, twoandfourteen said:

 

I don’t know. If you actually go through rosters team-by-team, you start to realize just how weak overall the Bills skill positions are relative to the rest of the league. I did the AFC earlier today and it’s eye-opening. 

 

Allen really is a supernatural force out there when you look at the scraps Beane has given him to work with... 

 

 

 

I don't think our starting trio is as weak as you think it is, but I do agree with this: Beane hasn't done Josh a lot of favors.  Earlier in his career, it was only Josh's athleticism that kept him somewhat upright.  You'd think a GM with a great QB would want to give him a great bodyguard.  Beane took his time with that.  

 

You'd also think that a GM would give his talented thrower some good guys to throw to.  Beane success with that has been a mixed bag.  I miss the days when the Bills had Reed, Lofton, and Beebe on the same roster.  

 

I'm afraid that when Josh retires and his critics, looking at the stats, assert he wasn't the GOAT or doesn't deserve the HOF or junk like that, his apologists will say, "Well, he had a sh*tty line for half his career and sh*tty receivers for the other half."

[balln]

8 minutes ago, SageAgainstTheMachine said:

The throw to Beasley from his own EZ in the 2019 Thanksgiving game vs the Cowboys.

Allen had a pass to Diggs to take the league only for hail Murray to happen. It was filthy 

 

he also had a similar pass to Diggs vs ne for a td- I believe the BB iPad smash game. 

 

[ChevyVanMiller]

Just found this, Some great locker room comments from Palmer, Coleman and Bosa  after the comeback win.