QB Comparisons to Josh, QB's from the Past and or the Present ?

[34-78-83]

Early Josh - most like John Elway

Current Josh - most like Steve Young

[Maine-iac]

Tried this once before and it gained little traction but I think there are many many similarities between Andrew Luck and Josh Allen.  Allen takes a lot of the things Luck used to do and takes it up a notch.  Allen has been better in the playoffs.  If Luck had played for Andy Reid or had Spags coaching his defense he probably would have made more noise in the playoffs.

Edited August 13 by Maine-iac

[ChronicAndKnuckles]

7 hours ago, julian said:

No player has had the combination of physical attributes that Allen has other than Cam, but Cam wasn’t the passer Allen is.

 

Cam/Big Ben/Favre/Elway

Cam isn’t the passer or leader he is. I could never see Josh not diving on a fumble in a regular season game let alone the biggest game of his life. Never has one play totally shifted my complete perception of a player. I used to be a fan.

[julian]

2 minutes ago, ChronicAndKnuckles said:

Cam isn’t the passer or leader he is. I could never see Josh not diving on a fumble in a regular season game let alone the biggest game of his life. Never has one play totally shifted my complete perception of a player. I used to be a fan.

100%… you’re not alone, many people including myself watched that play and were shocked.